All schools in Upshur County will close at 1 p.m. today. All B-UHS sporting events today are canceled.

Buckhannon man arrested after one person shot, another stabbed in botched armed robbery attempt

Hunter Michael Aragon
Hunter Michael Aragon

A Buckhannon man is in jail on $150,000 cash-only bond after an armed robbery attempt ended with one subject being shot in the face and the victim beaten and stabbed.

Hunter Michael Aragon, 21, of Buckhannon is charged with first-degree robbery, malicious wounding, wanton endangerment with a firearm, presentation of a firearm during the commission of a felony and conspiracy to commit a felony, according to the criminal complaint filed in the Randolph County Magistrate Clerk’s Office.

According to Cpl. C.G. Boatwright with the Elkins Police Department, two men – Aragon and a second man that Aragon identified as Damien Moore – attempted to rob an apartment on Davis Avenue at about 10:30 p.m. on Monday, Dec. 9.

Aragon told police that “he had heard someone had stuff that could make him some money, so he asked Damien for help.”

Upon arriving at the apartment, the two became involved in an altercation with Kelvin Akerley, according to the file.

“Hunter states that once they made entry into the apartment, they began to fight the ‘big mother [expletive]’ and kept telling him to ‘shut the [expletive] up’ and attempted to cover his mouth,” Boatwright writes in the complaint.

During the struggle, the firearm – later identified as a sawed-off shotgun – went off, hitting Moore in the jaw. Moore was “completely missing his lower jaw” when officers found him, according to the complaint.

Aragon then used a knife, brass knuckles and a liquor bottle to attack Akerley.

“Once Kelvin was down, Hunter states he began to flee with Damien down the stairs until we arrived and took him into custody,” Boatwright says in the complaint.

Boatwright and Senior Patrolman D.T. Sayre entered the apartment building, at which time “I topped the stairs and observed a large amount of blood in the hallway outside of Apartment 2,” Boatwright writes.

“I then saw the door begin to open and then slam,” he continues. “I announced myself and attempted to make entry. A male subject had himself against the door, refusing my entry. I then kicked the door twice, at which time he backed up and showed me his hands. The male subject, then identified as Kelvin Akerley, was covered in blood and was obviously very distraught.”

Boatwright says Akerley told officers the two individuals were running out the back, and he followed a trail of blood to the rear steps and out the door.

“I then exited the building and made contact with one male subject that was completely missing his lower jaw, bleeding terribly, and still attempting to flee with a backpack on,” the officer writes in the complaint. “I then observed another male subject with a knife in his hand around the corner of the wall to my left.”

Both men surrendered. Moore was taken to Davis Medical Center, according to the file, while officers interviewed Aragon.

Boatwright says Aragon “showed no remorse during the interview” and later made additional threats.

The officer also interviewed Akerley, who told him two men in masks entered his residence and threatened to kill him. He suffered two stab wounds, Boatwright notes.

Aragon is being held in Tygart Valley Regional Jail.

Share this story:

RECENT Stories

Softball Lady Bucs survive elimination behind Abel’s three-run home run as they down Preston, 6-3

Alyssa Abel’s three-run homer in the first inning powered the Buckhannon-Upshur Lady Bucs to a 6-3 victory over Preston, keeping their softball season alive in the Region I Section 2 tournament.

Buckhannon Banter: Get the local lowdown for May 8, 2025

Buckhannon’s recent news tidbits include a student art exhibit, a dinosaur-themed family event, library programs for kids, and volunteers paddling the Buckhannon River to assess conditions for the upcoming race.

Bucs place 10th at Big 10 Conference track and field championships

The Buckhannon-Upshur Buccaneers placed 10th out of 13 teams at the Big 10 Conference track and field championships, highlighted by a third-place finish in the 4×800-meter relay.

Track and Field Lady Bucs run 12th at Big 10 Conference Championships

The Buckhannon-Upshur Lady Bucs track team finished 12th out of 13 teams at the Big 10 Conference Championships, scoring in four events, with Gwen Rogoksy leading in the 3200 meters.

Eight honored with 2025 Order of Augusta, Ty Landis of Buckhannon recognized as a WVU outstanding senior

Graduating in the top 1% of the class, Ty Landis of Buckhannon has been named a WVU Outstanding Senior for his academic achievements and leadership as part of the West Virginia University Class of 2025.

Highland Landscaping continues to roll in Bob Cupp Memorial Golf League

Highland Landscaping extended its lead in the Bob Cupp Memorial Golf League to 13½ points after a 22-18 win over Hank Ellis Insurance, while Lisa Cain Edward Jones moved into third place in the standings.

Buckhannon Community Theatre brings whimsical magic to life in ‘Alice in Wonderland’

Buckhannon Community Theatre’s vibrant production of “Alice in Wonderland,” featuring a diverse cast and whimsical costumes, opens this weekend at the Colonial Arts Center, offering family-friendly entertainment.
WVWC Track - Wesleyan Sports

Wesleyan catcher Andie Dizon selected to First-Team All-Region Softball Team

Wesleyan catcher Andie Dizon was named to the 2025 NFCA Division II First-Team All-Region after batting .451 with 38 RBIs in 52 games and is now eligible for All-America honors.

Upshur County man arrested after allegedly talking about shooting elementary school students in online chat

An Upshur County man was arrested after allegedly admitting to posting online threats to shoot elementary school students and kill his parents, leading to a felony charge of making terroristic threats.

Annette Fetty-Santilli is a top fundraiser at Pittsburgh PurpleStride

Annette Fetty-Santilli of Clarksburg was one of the top three fundraisers at Pittsburgh PurpleStride, raising over $16,000 for pancreatic cancer research as captain of Team West Virginia.

Buckhannon Banter: Get the local lowdown for May 7, 2025

Today’s Banter spotlights youth events, the library seed program, upcoming community gatherings, and more, offering residents ways to connect, have fun, and support local initiatives.

Register today: Youth mountain biking event ready to roll on Upshur County Trails May 10

A free youth mountain biking “Try It” event for students in grades 6–12, offering bikes and helmets for those without, will be held May 10 at Upshur County Trails to promote cycling, teamwork and community.