City switches from self-funded health insurance plan to PEIA

BUCKHANNON – Less than a year after switching to a partially self-funded health insurance plan for its employees, the City of Buckhannon is switching back to a fully funded plan – this time through the Public Employees Insurance Agency.

In May 2019, council voted to transfer city employees’ health care coverage from longtime health insurance carrier Blue Cross Blue Shield to a partially self-insurance health insurance plan administered through Tawney Insurance and Consulting Services LLC.

However, during its March 19 meeting, city council voted unanimously to again move its employee health care coverage from its current provider, Tawney Insurance and Consulting, to PEIA.

Under the partially self-insured plan, the city assumed some financial responsibility and paid employees’ claims out-of-pocket up to a certain cap per employee per year, and city officials said that method was both costlier and more cumbersome than they expect a fully funded plan under PEIA to be.

A fully funded plan – like the one the city will switch to on July 1 – means an entity pays a set monthly premium; however, the cost of partially self-funded health insurance fluctuates depending on the cost and number of claims.

Pete Thackston, senior vice president with USI Insurance Services, attended the March 19 meeting to answer any council questions before members voted on the matter. Thackston also served as consultant to the Upshur County Commission when it recently switched from a fully self-funded health care plan to PEIA.

“In recent weeks, we’ve had conversations with Pete Thackston, who is senior vice president with USI Insurance Services, and is a consultant with the PEIA,” Mayor David McCauley said. “We’ve seen a lot of information about cost-savings without a compromise to our employees’ health insurance needs.”

The mayor said if the city switched from Tawney Insurance to coverage under the Public Employees Insurance Agency, the city would save about $500,000 annually.

Councilman CJ Rylands asked Thackston to explain the difference between an HSA, a health savings account, and an HRA, a health reimbursement account – two possible features under PEIA plans.

Thackston described an HRA as a “more limited form of assisting the employees and their dependents in that it is basically set up for medical, dental or vision expenses.”

Under an HRA, if a set amount of money allocated isn’t used by the employee, the money reverts back to the city.

“So, there’s no real flexibility other than what it’s doing is assisting in covering out-of-pocket expenses to play claims on an ongoing basis,” Thackston said. “It is city money … you apply ‘X’ amount to the plan for single or family. It is city money the whole time, but with the HSA it becomes the employees’ money.”

McCauley asked if employees might be more reluctant to seek medical care under an HSA because they’d be essentially spending their own money – not ‘city money.’

“Have you found with HSAs … that employees might be more reluctant with an HSA versus the other plan, to not pursue health stuff because it’s like, ‘I don’t want to tap into my money’?” the mayor asked.

Thackston said yes.

“On the HRA side, theoretically speaking, it’s free money, so ‘if I use it, I use it, if I don’t, I don’t,’” he said. “It’s free money. Conversely, the HSA is a much more flexible plan, if you will, because you can use it for savings, investing, etc. etc., not to mention that you can use it for premiums, for COBRA, Medicare down the road and that kind of thing.”

An HSA is a much “broader benefit” that’s tax-free if used for qualified purposes, Thackston said.

“Think of it as a 401k driven by medical,” he said.

Rylands said he thought an HSA could potentially shake out to be similar to a retirement plan.

“I think we’re kind of crossing a bridge over into an enhanced retirement account of some sort … [it seems like] we’re trying to do two things with one, and I’d like to try to delineate. I want to provide services yet be prudent with funds so we can continue to [cover] those deductibles.”

Councilman David Thomas said he wanted to point out that a $500,000 cost-savings wouldn’t equate to a lower quality of health care for employees.

“It’s not a reduction in quality of care but a comprehensive cost-savings,” Thomas said, “and I just want people to be aware of that.”

City finance and administrative director Amberle Jenkins said keeping the books for the current partially self-funded plan the city is not only more expense than a fully funded plan, but also more stressful.

“It is much more work to maintain records for this type of insurance, and I’m not an insurance agent, so it’s kind of uncomfortable to make decisions about coverage,” she said.

“The most recent question I had was about whether we were going to cover testing for the pandemic and how to fund that,” Jenkins added. “It’s become difficult and worrisome.”

The city will remain on its current plan through June 30, 2020, when it then expects to switch to PEIA.

“I think if the savings was $50,000, maybe we would scratch our heads a little but with half-a-million dollars in savings, I don’t know how we could do anything else,” McCauley said.

As of the end of the March 19 meeting, council hadn’t decided which plan under PEIA to select, but council members did vote unanimously to switch from partially self-insured to a PEIA fully funded plan.

Rylands made a motion to transfer health coverage to PEIA, effective July 1, 2020, which was seconded by councilwoman Pam Bucklew prior to passing unanimously.

Featured

SHOPS & SERVICES

Buckhannon man held on $100,000 bail after being arrested on multiple drug charges

BUCKHANNON – A Buckhannon man was arrested Saturday after several illegal substances were allegedly found in his residence. Bryan Shaw, 41, of Buckhannon, was arrested for possession with intent to deliver methamphetamine, possession with intent to deliver heroin, possession with […]

Become a premium member to unlock immediate access to this story and thousands more. Plus you’ll wake up every morning to our email edition. Your subscription supports local news by local writers. Signing up is easy — just tap the button below!

Buckhannon City Council approves $6.5 million-dollar budget prioritizing public safety, infrastructure

BUCKHANNON – City council passed the largest budget in Buckhannon’s history Tuesday, with the two largest allocations once again earmarked for public safety operations and infrastructure maintenance, respectively. At its March 14 meeting – rescheduled from March 16 due to […]

Become a premium member to unlock immediate access to this story and thousands more. Plus you’ll wake up every morning to our email edition. Your subscription supports local news by local writers. Signing up is easy — just tap the button below!

Police arrest man they say was the driver in 2022 pursuit that ended in a wreck with two people ejected

BUCKHANNON – A Rock Cave man was arrested for allegedly fleeing from police officers in a vehicle, injuring himself and a passenger. Elijah Carpenter, 27, of Rock Cave was arrested Thursday for fleeing from an officer and fleeing or attempting […]

Become a premium member to unlock immediate access to this story and thousands more. Plus you’ll wake up every morning to our email edition. Your subscription supports local news by local writers. Signing up is easy — just tap the button below!

SHOPS & SERVICES

Softball Lady Bucs get one-hit by Lincoln’s Haller in debut in 10-0 setback

TENNERTON – For their season opener, the Buckhannon-Upshur softball Lady Bucs ran into one of the top pitchers in the state in Lincoln’s Delaney Haller. Haller was the Big 10 Conference Pitcher of the Year last season and was captain […]

Become a premium member to unlock immediate access to this story and thousands more. Plus you’ll wake up every morning to our email edition. Your subscription supports local news by local writers. Signing up is easy — just tap the button below!

Baseball ‘Cats get home doubleheader split with ABU

BUCKHANNON, W.Va. – The West Virginia Wesleyan baseball team split with the Alderson Broaddus Battlers Monday, winning 7-2 in the first game and losing 7-0 in the second game. The bats were alive in Game

Inexperienced tennis Bucs fall in first two outings of 2023 season

BRIDGEPORT – The Buckhannon-Upshur tennis Buccaneers dropped their first two outings of the year last week. They opened their season at home last Thursday with a 7-0 setback to Robert C. Byrd and then went to Bridgeport Saturday and dropped […]

Become a premium member to unlock immediate access to this story and thousands more. Plus you’ll wake up every morning to our email edition. Your subscription supports local news by local writers. Signing up is easy — just tap the button below!

Lady Buc netters open season with win over Robert C. Byrd and narrow loss to John Marshall

BRIDGEPORT – The Buckhannon-Upshur Lady Buc tennis team is off to a 1-1 start to the season and was just an eyelash away from being a perfect 2-0. The Lady Bucs hosted Robert C. Byrd last Thursday and won a […]

Become a premium member to unlock immediate access to this story and thousands more. Plus you’ll wake up every morning to our email edition. Your subscription supports local news by local writers. Signing up is easy — just tap the button below!

SHOPS & SERVICES

Working in service: WVU research reaches all of West Virginia

Breakthroughs and research expertise nurtured at West Virginia University extend far beyond its labs, experimental sites and classrooms. In fact, WVU research efforts are unique compared to most universities, according to Vice President for Research Fred King. “While

Fairmont State University selects 2023 Presidential Scholarship winners

Three incoming Fairmont State University freshmen have been selected as the recipients of Fairmont State’s premier academic scholarship, the Charles J. McClain Presidential Scholarship. Sophie Stuart from Jefferson High School (Charles town, W.VA), Hailey Jordan

WVDEP hosting students on World Water Day

CHARLESTON, WV – In an effort to enrich students’ understanding of the importance of clean water, the West Virginia Department of Environmental Protection (WVDEP) is hosting a water education event for area grade schools on