All schools in Upshur County will close at 1 p.m. today. All B-UHS sporting events today are canceled.

Police: Summersville man, Buckhannon woman allegedly conspired to steal copper from building

BUCKHANNON – A Nicholas County man and an Upshur County woman were arrested for allegedly stealing copper from a building at a location referred to as Terrace Avenue in Upshur County.

Seth Imhoff, 36, of Summersville, was arrested for conspiracy, a felony, and entry of a building other than a dwelling, a misdemeanor. Michelle Tomey, 27, of Buckhannon was arrested for conspiracy, a felony.

According to the criminal complaint in the Upshur County Magistrate Clerk’s Office filed by Trooper First Class P.J. Robinette with the Buckhannon detachment of the West Virginia State Police on July 4, 2022, at approximately 8:16 a.m., Imhoff allegedly entered a building with the “physical address of 5 Terrace Avenue” without breaking. The police report says Imhoff allegedly entered the building by a hole, which had previously been cut into the wall and subsequently stole copper from within.

Imhoff was reportedly captured on film committing the act and later allegedly admitted to his actions during a recorded interview with another state police trooper.

During the investigation, it was determined Imhoff was with his girlfriend, Tomey, during the time of the theft and law enforcement officers allege she had prior knowledge of items inside the building. Tomey allegedly waited outside while Imhoff entered the building and then used her car to transport the stolen copper.

Upshur County Magistrate Alan Suder set bail at $20,000 cash or surety for Imhoff and $10,000 cash or surety for Tomey.

The potential penalty for a conviction of entry of a building other than a dwelling is a fine of up to $100 and confinement in the regional jail for two to 12 months.

The potential penalty for a conviction of felony conspiracy is confinement in the state penitentiary for one to 10 years.

Share this story:

Local Businesses

RECENT Stories

Ronald Earl “Ronnie” Grall Sr.

Ronald Earl “Ronnie” Grall Sr., 83, of Buckhannon, a 2006 Sago Mine Disaster survivor and former coal mine fire boss, died December 29, 2025; he is survived by his wife Helen, five children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren.

Upshur County Sports Calendar

Upshur County sports schedule runs Dec. 29–Jan. 4 with multiple Buckhannon-Upshur basketball games in winter classics and out-of-state tournaments, wrestling entries in Powerade and regional meets, and a Mohawk Invitational swim.

WVWC’s Witt named MEC Women’s Basketball Player of the Week

West Virginia Wesleyan senior Emma Witt and Concord’s Alexis Frazee were named co–MEC Women’s Basketball Players of the Week after Witt’s 30-point double-double and Frazee’s 20.5-point weekly average.

Driver cited after triggering three-vehicle crash on Main Street that damaged police car, hit Buckhannon bank

A Beverly woman allegedly ran a stop sign on Main Street in Buckhannon, causing a Dec. 27 crash that involved three vehicles and struck the First Community Bank building, according to the Upshur County Sheriff’s Department’s wreck report.

Woman extricated after Route 33 crash near Huddle House; truck driver cited

A Salem woman was trapped in her vehicle and had to be extricated after a two-vehicle crash on Route 33 north of the Huddle House. Police say a truck driver attempting to cross lanes to turn left was cited for failing to yield.

Bryan Lynn Fitzgerald

Bryan Lynn Fitzgerald, 68, of French Creek, WV, died December 24, 2025, in Morgantown and is survived by his family, with cremation and private services planned.

On the City of Buckhannon Calendar: Week of Dec. 29, 2025

No regularly scheduled meetings this week. City offices and waste collection closed January 1 for New Year’s Day.

Buckhannon man charged after allegedly breaking into trailer, fighting resident

A Buckhannon man was arrested after allegedly breaking into a home and fighting with one of the occupants. He faces charges including burglary, destruction of property, assault and battery.

Buckhannon woman charged with using elderly man’s bank card online

A Buckhannon woman was arrested after police say she used another person’s bank card information for multiple unauthorized transactions totaling about $1,201.29. She said the transactions were not intentional, and his card might have been saved to her online payments account.