All schools in Upshur County will close at 1 p.m. today. All B-UHS sporting events today are canceled.

Police arrest employee for allegedly stealing catalytic converter from tow company lot

BUCKHANNON – A Buckhannon man was arrested Thursday for allegedly attempting to steal a catalytic converter from a vehicle on his employer’s tow lot.

Justin Knicely, 25, of Buckhannon was arrested for grand larceny.

According to the criminal complaint in the Upshur County Magistrate Clerk’s Office, on Thursday, Aug. 4, the owner of A+S Towing called the Upshur County 911 Center and reported an employee, Knicely, was allegedly in the process of stealing a catalytic converter off one of the vehicles, a Jeep Liberty parked at the company lot.

“The defendant was found by officers by the wrecked vehicle,” Sgt. Theron Caynor with the Upshur County Sheriff’s Office wrote in the complaint. “A reciprocating saw was in the front of his vehicle and the converter was in the side toolbox of the truck. The owner stated he did not have permission to cut any parts off of the vehicles there.”

Knicely told deputies that the office manager had told him to remove the catalytic converter and bring it to him, which the manager denied, according to the complaint. In a video statement, another employee told officers that Knicely said he was going to cut a converter off for gas money.

The replacement value of the catalytic converter was $4,755, the file notes.

Bail was set at $15,000 cash or surety by Upshur County Magistrate Alan Suder.

The potential penalty for grand larceny is confinement in the penitentiary for not less than one nor more than 10 years, or in the discretion of the court, confinement in jail for not more than one year and a fine of not more than $2,500.

Share this story:

Local Businesses

RECENT Stories

Criminal complaint reveals new details about Hitt’s alleged home confinement violation

A new criminal complaint says a man already on GPS home confinement for terroristic threats involving an elementary school is now charged with misdemeanor obstructing after allegedly setting his devices to auto-delete their internet history and creating a TikTok he couldn’t let officers access.

Upshur County Commission Agenda: December 4, 2025

The Upshur County Commission will hold a meeting on December 4, 2025, with an agenda posted by My Buckhannon outlining items to be discussed.

Stockert Youth and Community Center Board Meeting Agenda: December 4, 2025

The Stockert Youth and Community Center Board will hold a meeting December 4, 2025, in Buckhannon to discuss the items listed on the published agenda.

Buckhannon City Council Agenda: December 4, 2025

Buckhannon City Council will meet December 4, 2025; the agenda for that meeting is posted.

Buckhannon man sentenced to 5 to 18 years in prison on drug, burglary and domestic battery charges

Jesse Todd Miller, 37, was sentenced Monday in Upshur County Circuit Court after pleading guilty to seven charges.

Raising the Jolly Roger With… Dawson Tenney

Buckhannon-Upshur senior Dawson Tenney reflects on a record-setting 60-57 win, coach Sloan Baisden’s “Standard Living” mantra, future college football and career plans.

Buckhannon Waste Board Agenda: December 4, 2025

The City of Buckhannon Waste Collection Board will hold a meeting December 4, 2025; this notice provides the agenda and topics to be addressed.

Buckhannon Consolidated Public Works Board Agenda: December 4, 2025

The Buckhannon Consolidated Public Works Board will meet December 4, 2025, and this notice outlines the meeting agenda.

West Virginia Wesleyan College to host regional music festival in January

West Virginia Wesleyan College will host a regional festival for WVMEA Solo and Ensemble Festival on Saturday, January 24. The event is open to solo instrumentalists, vocalists, small ensembles and pianists, with a registration deadline of January 10.