All schools in Upshur County will close at 1 p.m. today. All B-UHS sporting events today are canceled.

Special agent investigated alleged solicitation of murder case, court documents show

BUCKHANNON – A person indicted in Upshur County Circuit Court Monday allegedly tried to poison a man three times and also attempted to hire another man to kill the victim, according to court documents.

Jaymie Wright, no age or hometown listed, was among the 24 individuals indicted Jan. 10, 2022, by an Upshur County grand jury. Wright was indicted on four felony charges: three counts of attempting to kill or injure by poison and one count of solicitation of murder.

According to the indictment filed in the Upshur County Circuit Clerk’s office Tuesday, Wright allegedly attempted to kill or injure the victim by placing various substances in his “food and/or beverages.” Wright allegedly attempted to administer aconite, a type of poisonous plant, on one occasion; “medication” on another occasion; and potassium on a third occasion.

The indictment also states that Wright “willingly and knowingly instigated or induced [a third party] to kill [the victim].”

The indictment is based on the testimony of Special Agent Wilmer Smithson III. The incidents reportedly occurred sometime between January 2020 and January 2021, according to court documents filed in the circuit clerk’s office.

Special prosecuting attorney Savannah Hull Wilkins, who serves as the Tucker County Prosecuting Attorney, presented the case to the grand jury Monday.

Other details about the case, however, are scant. Upshur County Prosecuting Attorney Bryan Hinkle did not immediately respond to a call about the case Tuesday, and Wilkins declined to comment.

If convicted, each count of attempting to kill or injure by poison carries a sentence between three and 18 years in state prison, while solicitation of murder has a sentence of three to 15 years in prison.

Share this story:

Local Businesses

RECENT Stories

Election Update: Latest local candidate filings as of Jan. 21

The candidate filing period is underway for West Virginia’s May 12, 2026, Primary Election. Here’s a rundown of who has filed so far for Upshur County and Buckhannon races.

Basketball Bucs move up to eighth in latest WVSACA poll

Buckhannon-Upshur moved up to eighth in the WVSACA poll at 8-3 after a 1-1 week, earning 36 points and preparing to face Class AAAA No. 6 University and Class AAA No. 6 East Fairmont.

Basketball Lady Bucs win second in a row; down Sissonvile, 57-44

Allie Key’s 16 points and 11 rebounds and strong bench play helped Buckhannon-Upshur beat Sissonville 57-44 for their second win of the season, with Madelyn Tucker and Aubrey Key adding 11 each.

Rock Cave man arrested on methamphetamine charge following traffic stop

A Rock Cave man was arrested on charges of possession with intent to deliver methamphetamine and conspiracy.

Upshur County Commission Agenda: January 22, 2026

The Upshur County Commission will hold a meeting on January 22, 2026, with the posted agenda outlining items for discussion and action.

Buckhannon man arrested for allegedly entering laundromat while it was closed

A Buckhannon man was arrested after allegedly entering the Speed Wash Laundromat after hours while another person stole from the quarter machine.

Upshur County students show gains in reading, math at mid-year benchmarks

Upshur County students posted mid-year gains on i-Ready benchmarks, with fewer students falling behind in both reading and math. Superintendent Christy Miller also flagged chronic absenteeism as a key focus.

Annette Reel

Annette Reel, 67, of Hurricane, WV, an FBI analyst and Christian Fellowship Church member, died January 18, 2026; she is survived by two children, five grandchildren, four siblings, and will be cremated with a later celebration of life.

Blanche Grace (Helmick) McCartney

Blanche Grace (Helmick) McCartney, 99, a former West Buckhannon Methodist Church choir member and longtime resident of the Buckhannon area, died January 18, 2026, leaving three sons, multiple descendants, and a large extended family.