All schools in Upshur County will close at 1 p.m. today. All B-UHS sporting events today are canceled.

Felony warrant for child neglect issued following investigation into Main Street fire

The Buckhannon Fire Department utilizes its ladder truck to ensure a June 20 fire in an apartment above Merle Norman is fully extinguished June 20. / File photo

BUCKHANNON – A felony warrant has been issued for the arrest of a Buckhannon man following the Buckhannon Police Department’s investigation of a structure fire that occurred June 20 on Main Street.

Buckhannon Police Chief Matt Gregory said Thursday that a warrant has been issued for the arrest of Melvin Tyler, 29, for child neglect creating risk of serious bodily injury.

The warrant is not for arson but is connected to the fire that broke out in a second-story apartment above Merle Norman and the Pink Hydrangea on Main Street Saturday, June 20. Gregory said Tyler, who is originally from Maryland, is the parent-guardian of three children – a five-year-old, a six-year-old and a seven-year-old – who were home at the time the fire started.

The children are safe, Gregory said, and no one was injured in the fire, according to a previous story.

It’s not clear exactly how long Tyler was at the residence during or after the fire started.

“He was there at one point, and then he left,” Gregory said of Tyler. “We do have a felony warrant for his arrest, but now he’s believed to have left the state. That’s the information we have received.”

Tyler is Black and stands 6 feet tall, weighing about 225 pounds, the police chief said. Anyone with information regarding his whereabouts is asked to call the police at 304-472-5723, the Upshur County E911 Communication Center at 304-472-9550 or leave a tip anonymously on the BPD’s website here.

Career firefighter John Brugnoli said the Buckhannon Fire Department had not received a report back on the cause of the fire from the state fire marshal’s office, which investigated the incident.

Gregory indicated the fire did not appear to be accidental.

“It was started,” he said.

Read the original story here.

Share this story:

Local Businesses

RECENT Stories

Former Buckhannon mayor sentenced to decade in prison for child pornography offense

David Walter McCauley, former Buckhannon mayor, was sentenced to 10 years in federal prison and 10 years supervised release for child pornography involving a 17-year-old boy, following an FBI-led investigation.

American Legion Post 7 cancels Flag Retirement Ceremony due to rain

The American Legion Post 7 has canceled its June 14 Flag Retirement Ceremony because of expected rain and thunderstorms, and will reschedule the event for a later date.

Sandra Louise Collins Garrison

Sandra Louise Collins Garrison, a longtime educator in Buckhannon, is remembered by family and former students following her death at age 73, with funeral services set for June 18 at Way of Holiness Church.
LUCAS Truck

LUCAS to offer lung cancer screening in Rock Cave, Weston, and Buckhannon

LUCAS, WVU Medicine’s mobile lung cancer screening unit, will offer low-dose CT scans in Rock Cave, Weston, and Buckhannon in July for insured and eligible uninsured patients by appointment.

Man arrested for allegedly attempting to cash unauthorized check at BC Bank in Buckhannon

Christian Lyons, 47, of Ashford, was arrested on a felony charge after allegedly attempting to cash a check without authorization at a Buckhannon bank, with surveillance and account details helping police identify him.
Summer basketball

Summer Basketball League continues to grow under UCRC director Mitchell Shaw

The Upshur County Summer Basketball League, overseen by UCRC director Mitchell Shaw, is thriving and expanding with 18 teams and 183 players, offering organized, community-focused competition and new sponsorship-driven prizes in Buckhannon.

Buckhannon Banter: Get the local lowdown for June 11, 2025

Local highlights include a June 28 Glow Stick Party at James Curry Library, Upshur Schools’ virtual learning signups, BUHS rescheduled Alumni Soccer Game and a debut novel by Chantelle Kerr.

Upshur Update: Catch up on the latest local news in our June 11, 2025 podcast

The Upshur Update highlights the return of the Almost Heaven BBQ Bash, pool openings with new inclusive programs, community achievements in literacy and sports, student honors, local recognitions, and upcoming summer events in Buckhannon and Upshur County.

‘It’s the Small Things that Count’ – Lively pens book about daughter Megan

Alisa Mauk Lively has written “It’s the Small Things that Count,” a book celebrating the life and impact of her late daughter Megan, with proceeds benefiting Upshur County Special Olympics.