All schools in Upshur County will close at 1 p.m. today. All B-UHS sporting events today are canceled.

Upshur County Prosecuting Attorney David Godwin retiring at November’s end

Upshur County Prosecuting Attorney David Godwin

BUCKHANNON – David Godwin began his career in the Upshur County Prosecuting Attorney’s office, and that’s where he’ll end it, too.

Godwin, who’s served as Upshur County prosecuting attorney since 2014, announced his upcoming retirement at the end of November this week.

While he was earning his J.D. at West Virginia University College of Law, he interned in the Upshur County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office and, upon graduating in May 1979, become the first ever assistant prosecuting attorney the county ever employed, according to his resume.

He remained in that post until May of 1984.

Now, four decades later, he’s decided it’s time to retire and spend time with family while he’s still in good health.

In an Oct. 22 letter to the Upshur County Commission, Godwin said his last day would be Nov. 30, 2019.

“It has been an honor to serve in this capacity for the last five years,” he wrote. “However, having spent over 40 years as a state and federal prosecutor, and with my 69th birthday fast-approaching, I need to retire and spend more time with my family while I have the good health to do so.”

“If there is any way I can ease the transition over the next month, please let me know how I can do so,” the letter concludes.

Upshur County Prosecuting Attorney David Godwin by the county courthouse / Photo courtesy Robbie Skinner

Godwin had little comment on his retirement Tuesday, saying his reasons were straightforward.

“I really appreciate being able to have the job, of course,” he said.

Godwin sent My Buckhannon his resume and work history, so we’ve pulled out a few highlights.

Godwin earned his Bachelor of Arts degree in government with a minor in history from West Virginia Wesleyan College in 1972 and was subsequently deployed to serve as an active duty officer in the U.S. Navy from June 1972 through August 1976. He was an air intelligence officer of Fighter Squadron 33 aboard the USS Independence prior to his honorable discharge as a lieutenant in 1976.

He then earned his law degree from WVU in 1979.

“I was then employed as the first assistant prosecuting attorney ever hired in Upshur County in May 1979 upon graduating law school,” he wrote in his work history.

From June 1984 through August 2014, his permanent position with the U.S. Justice Department was assistant U.S. attorney for the Northern District of West Virginia, although he undertook a variety of roles and assignments.

Of note, in the late 1980s and early 1990s, he prosecuted several individuals who were connected to eight house fires and the death of a young girl, who perished in one of the fires in French Creek, and the “maiming” of another man. Around that time, he prosecuted a case involving the attempted assassination of then-Upshur County Sheriff Fred Gaudet.

Referring to the string of house fires, Godwin wrote, “The case brought to an end the deadly rampage of arson in the southern part of Upshur County and resulted in lengthy prison sentences” for the two implicated individuals.

In 1998, Godwin was honored with the Director’s Award for his handling of the prosecution of the case involving the West Virginia Mountaineer Militia, which in 1997, resulted in the first convictions obtained by the government under the 1994, “Material to Support Terrorists’” statute, according to Godwin.

The Mountaineer Militia was a paramilitary group, members of which were arrested Oct. 12, 1996 for the roles in what a digitized New York Times article said was a plot to plant bombs at several government buildings in West Virginia, “among them the FBI’s automated fingerprint center and the state capital in Charleston.”

While working for the Northern District of West Virginia, he spent six years serving on the Upshur County Board of Education from 1988-1994.

Most recently, in August 2014, Godwin served as assistant Upshur County prosecuting attorney for a short stint before transitioning into his current role in December.

Godwin’s resignation/retirement letter is listed as informational on the commission’s agenda for its 9 a.m. meeting Thursday, Oct. 24.

Share this story:

Local Businesses

RECENT Stories

Former Buckhannon mayor sentenced to decade in prison for child pornography offense

David Walter McCauley, former Buckhannon mayor, was sentenced to 10 years in federal prison and 10 years supervised release for child pornography involving a 17-year-old boy, following an FBI-led investigation.

American Legion Post 7 cancels Flag Retirement Ceremony due to rain

The American Legion Post 7 has canceled its June 14 Flag Retirement Ceremony because of expected rain and thunderstorms, and will reschedule the event for a later date.

Sandra Louise Collins Garrison

Sandra Louise Collins Garrison, a longtime educator in Buckhannon, is remembered by family and former students following her death at age 73, with funeral services set for June 18 at Way of Holiness Church.
LUCAS Truck

LUCAS to offer lung cancer screening in Rock Cave, Weston, and Buckhannon

LUCAS, WVU Medicine’s mobile lung cancer screening unit, will offer low-dose CT scans in Rock Cave, Weston, and Buckhannon in July for insured and eligible uninsured patients by appointment.

Man arrested for allegedly attempting to cash unauthorized check at BC Bank in Buckhannon

Christian Lyons, 47, of Ashford, was arrested on a felony charge after allegedly attempting to cash a check without authorization at a Buckhannon bank, with surveillance and account details helping police identify him.
Summer basketball

Summer Basketball League continues to grow under UCRC director Mitchell Shaw

The Upshur County Summer Basketball League, overseen by UCRC director Mitchell Shaw, is thriving and expanding with 18 teams and 183 players, offering organized, community-focused competition and new sponsorship-driven prizes in Buckhannon.

Buckhannon Banter: Get the local lowdown for June 11, 2025

Local highlights include a June 28 Glow Stick Party at James Curry Library, Upshur Schools’ virtual learning signups, BUHS rescheduled Alumni Soccer Game and a debut novel by Chantelle Kerr.

Upshur Update: Catch up on the latest local news in our June 11, 2025 podcast

The Upshur Update highlights the return of the Almost Heaven BBQ Bash, pool openings with new inclusive programs, community achievements in literacy and sports, student honors, local recognitions, and upcoming summer events in Buckhannon and Upshur County.

‘It’s the Small Things that Count’ – Lively pens book about daughter Megan

Alisa Mauk Lively has written “It’s the Small Things that Count,” a book celebrating the life and impact of her late daughter Megan, with proceeds benefiting Upshur County Special Olympics.