All schools in Upshur County will close at 1 p.m. today. All B-UHS sporting events today are canceled.

Buckhannon woman indicted for murder in fatal Randolph County shooting

Vanessa Logan

ELKINS – A Randolph County grand jury returned a total of 52 indictments during its Monday and Tuesday session, including two individuals with ties to Upshur County.

The cases were presented by Randolph County Prosecuting Attorney Michael W. Parker, with one presentation by Tucker County Prosecuting Attorney Ray LaMora III.

Vanessa Fay Logan, 32, who is currently an inmate at Lakin Correctional Center, was indicted on one count of murder, a felony.

The U. S. Marshals Service arrested Logan in late November after police believe she shot Spencer Zoller, 49, in Randolph County earlier in the month. She was apprehended at a trailer park about 15 miles from Morgantown.

According to Randolph County Sheriff Mark Brady, Zoller was found dead from a gunshot wound at a residence on Gum Road in the Crystal Springs are Nov. 18. Logan had allegedly fled the scene prior to the arrival of law enforcement; however, Brady had said there were several other individuals at the residence and spoke with law enforcement.

A previous My Buckhannon story said the sheriff’s department believed the shooting was drug-related.

In December 2018, Randolph County Magistrate Robert Elbon set bond at $150,000 cash-only for Logan, who was then being held without bond at the North Central Regional Jail.

Christopher Warren Koch, 32, was also indicted by the Randolph County Grand Jury in the June term on one count of accessory after the fact to murder, a felony.

Koch, of Elkins, who was employed in Upshur County at the time of the incident according to Brady, allegedly aided Logan as she evaded law enforcement.

The November 2018 sheriff’s office press release stated, “Koch was arrested on a felony charge of accessory after the fact relating to the homicide investigation of Spencer Zoller” and said during the investigation it was determined that Christopher Koch was “instrumental in assisting the murder suspect, Vanessa Logan, in evading law enforcement.”

According to a previous My Buckhannon story, Koch allegedly “provided transportation” to Logan and “assisted her in locating a place to stay to avoid arrest.” In addition, the release said (Koch) helped her secure items to change her personal appearance in an effort to further avoid detection” and said he also was trying to provide financial support to Logan.

Those indicted during the grand jury’s June term will report to the Randolph County Courthouse on Monday, July 1 at 9 a.m. for bond return hearings at which time bond will be set and trial dates will be determined.

The Randolph County Prosecuting Attorney’s office noted in the press release Tuesday that, “the fact that a defendant has been charged with a crime is merely an accusation and all defendants are presumed innocent until and unless proven guilty.”

Share this story:

RECENT Stories

WVWC Tennis

Tennis ‘Cats fall in Atlantic Regional battle to Davis & Elkins, 4-3

Davis & Elkins edged West Virginia Wesleyan 4-3 in their first NCAA Division II Men’s Tennis Atlantic Regional appearance to advance, while Fairmont State swept Shaw 4-0 to move on to the next round.

Lady Bucs softball season ends with loss to University in postseason tournament

The Buckhannon-Upshur Lady Bucs softball team saw their season end with a 17-0 loss to University in the Section 2, Region 1 Tournament, managing just one hit in the five-inning game.

Lacrosse Lady Bucs drop close playoff outing to Morgantown, 6-5

Despite defeating Morgantown twice in the regular season, the Buckhannon-Upshur Lady Bucs were eliminated from the state quarterfinals after a close 6-5 loss, ending their season with a 5-6 record.

B-U’s Jeffries claims No. 4 singles title at Big 10 Conference tennis championships

Buckhannon-Upshur’s Jeremiah Jeffries, in his first year playing tennis, captured the No. 4 singles title at the Big 10 Conference championships, leading a strong singles showing for the Buccaneers.

Cook wins Big 10 Conference tennis title at No. 4 singles for Lady Bucs

Patience Cook, a senior and first-year full-time varsity player for Buckhannon-Upshur, won the Big 10 Conference girls tennis title at No. 4 singles, leading a strong Lady Bucs team effort.

Buckhannon Banter: Get the local lowdown for May 9, 2025

Recent Buckhannon news includes special hours and events for the Strawberry Festival, recognition for local students, community theatre and band performances, volunteer calls, and more.

Two people charged with felony for harassing social media posts

Triston A. Thompson and Rachel C. Long of Buckhannon were arrested on a felony charge after allegedly harassing and threatening a road rage victim on social media.

Free behavior therapy group for teens launches in Buckhannon on May 15

The Mountain CAP Family Support Center and Child Advocacy Center are launching a free weekly behavior therapy group for Buckhannon teens ages 14-18 starting May 15, with pre-registration required.

Buckhannon council advances ordinances to curb 24/7 generator noise, clarify dwelling requirements

Buckhannon City Council unanimously approved the first readings of two ordinances in response to ongoing complaints, aiming to limit non-emergency generator use and clarify habitable property standards requiring essential utilities.

Norman Denver Hanifan

Norman Denver Hanifan, 84, a farmer from Tallmansville, died May 8, 2025, and is survived by three daughters, numerous grandchildren and siblings; funeral services are scheduled for May 10 at Poling-St. Clair Funeral Home.

Seventeen graduating service scholars contribute 9,900 service hours to community

Seventeen graduating students from West Virginia Wesleyan College’s Service Scholar program contributed over 9,900 hours, valued at nearly $87,000, to various community organizations while gaining hands-on leadership and service experience.

Softball Lady Bucs survive elimination behind Abel’s three-run home run as they down Preston, 6-3

Alyssa Abel’s three-run homer in the first inning powered the Buckhannon-Upshur Lady Bucs to a 6-3 victory over Preston, keeping their softball season alive in the Region I Section 2 tournament.