All schools in Upshur County will close at 1 p.m. today. All B-UHS sporting events today are canceled.

Negotiations between city officials, Knights of Pythias stall as fraternal organization vows not to sell property

City attorney Tom O'Neill says negotiations between the city and the Knights of Pythias over the property at 65 E. Main St. are likely to become increasingly complex.

BUCKHANNON – A local fraternal organization says its offer to sell its building to the City of Buckhannon for the purpose of expanding the Stockert Youth & Community Center is now off the table.

Following months of negotiations, talks have broken down between the Knights of Pythias and the city, with the Knights saying city officials have not kept their word and the city balking at the Knights’ asking price of $187,000, nearly double what the city has offered.

The proposed transaction between the city and the fraternal organization came about as a result of the city’s plan to expand SYCC. City officials and members of the SYCC Board want to acquire the property – located at 65 E. Main St. – because they believe it’s an ideal location for the construction of a $400,000 multi-use gymnasium/auditorium facility that would be connected to SYCC.

At council’s Thursday, Nov. 21 meeting, city attorney Tom O’Neill said the Knights of Pythias had secured an attorney, Allison Farrell of Jenkins Fenstermaker PLLC in Clarksburg, after they received a letter from O’Neill informing the Knights the city planned to acquire the property through condemnation and eminent domain proceedings if the fraternal organization did not lower their asking price.

“This is going to get increasingly complicated as time goes on,” O’Neill said at Thursday’s meeting.

Farrell’s Nov. 7 reply to O’Neill’s letter says the Knights “do not desire to sell their property located at 65 East Main Street.”

“Should the city still desire to initiate condemnation proceedings, please direct copies of the pleadings to me as counsel for the Knights,” it states.

On Friday, McCauley said the city had the property appraised by Dean Everett for $105,000, and he indicated the Knights of Pythias had a separate appraisal that came in under that value.

“We offered the middle of the two appraisals first, then ultimately increased it to the high appraised value (of $105,000),” the mayor said. The Knights of Pythias countered with an $187,000 offer, which the city rejected.

McCauley and Knights of Pythias treasurer Warren DeBarr both indicated negotiations broke down when discussions about the city building the Knights of Pythias a new lodge inside the new gymnasium/multi-purpose facility fell through.

The mayor said the group asked if the city would consider the possibility of building them a lodge inside the facility.

“We said we’d explore it,” McCauley said. “They wanted perpetual, forever ownership of a part of our building, built by taxpayers and … the (W.Va.) Ethics Commission indicated we couldn’t do that.”

When reached for comment Sunday, DeBarr said the city hadn’t been forthcoming.

“It’s not for sale,” DeBarr said. “We’ve been lied to so many times. [City officials] said they would build us a Lodge Hall in the new Stockert building free of charge, and they were going to build us a kitchen and a meeting room and a closet, but then they started backing out. The mayor said the [state] Ethics Commission and, I think, the attorney general’s office may not allow that.”

McCauley said Sunday the cost of the lodge the Knights wanted totaled $187,000 – the amount they are holding out for. However, DeBarr, who’s been a member of the group for 47 years, said the city had committed to building the facility and then reneged on their commitment.

“Now that they’re talking about condemning the building, and it’s not in bad shape. We got a lawyer,” he said. “We’re not going to sell them the building now.”

DeBarr said the group meets twice a month on Tuesdays in the building, and although the water’s been turned off, other utilities, including electric, remain on. He also insisted there’s a larger lot behind the Knights’ plot on which the new building could be constructed.

Meanwhile, McCauley said the city will move forward with plans to expand SYCC.

“We need the property for the kids, and we’re not going to be held hostage by this group and pay two, three, four or five times what it’s worth. It would be different if we were a private organization, but this is a public government,” McCauley said.

The mayor said city officials consider the property ideal, given its location across from city hall.

“It would add to the dense feeling of Main Street, it’s out of the floodplain, we wouldn’t have to move the basketball court, there’s 100 reasons why.”

McCauley said the building has no historical value, while DeBarr said the Knights of Pythias acquired the building in 1914 and have been meeting there for 105 years.

Chapter 54 of state code outlines eminent domain and procedures governing it. Eminent domain is the right of a government to acquire private property for public use.

The city may file litigation to acquire the lot prior to the end of 2019, McCauley said.

Share this story:

RECENT Stories

Turn the page on a long winter: Little Free Libraries are the perfect Spring activity

Little Free Libraries in Upshur County offer free books at numerous locations, fostering community connections and literacy for all ages while encouraging residents to donate, borrow, and share a wide variety of reading materials.

The Colonial Arts Center & CAC Gallery Present: 2025 Vandalia Arts Journal Exhibition

The CAC Gallery will host the inaugural exhibition of The Vandalia Arts Journal from April 25 to May 10, featuring WV Wesleyan College students’ literary and visual works.

Upshur County FFA members compete in the West Virginia Beef Stockman’s Contest at the 2025 Beef Expo

Four Upshur County FFA members gained hands-on experience and new skills while competing in knowledge and evaluation events at the West Virginia Beef Stockman’s Contest during the Beef Expo at WVU Jackson’s Mill.

Buckhannon Zoning Board of Appeals Agenda: May 28, 2025

The City of Buckhannon has released the agenda and public notice for its Zoning Board of Appeals meeting scheduled for May 28, 2025.

Baseball suffers losses to Point Pleasant and University

The Buckhannon-Upshur baseball team fell to Point Pleasant 8-5 then suffered a 16-0 shutout against University, dropping their record to 7-11.

Softball Lady Bucs take down Bearcats by an 8-3 score

Kynnedy Marple pitched a complete-game three-hitter and contributed offensively as Buckhannon-Upshur defeated Grafton 8-3 in a Big 10 Conference softball game, improving the Lady Bucs’ record to 9-7.

Highland Landscaping takes week one lead in men’s golf league standings

Highland Landscaping claimed an early lead in the Buckhannon Country Club Bob Cupp Memorial Golf League, defeating Feola’s Flowers and topping the standings after the opening week of play.

Wesleyan misses out on MEC post season lacrosse tournament as seeds and pairings announced

West Virginia Wesleyan College did not qualify for the 2025 Mountain East Conference Women’s Lacrosse Tournament as seeds and pairings were announced Thursday, with play set to begin Sunday.

Wesleyan lacrosse ends year with 23-5 loss to Charleston

West Virginia Wesleyan women’s lacrosse fell 23-5 to Charleston in their final regular season game, with Charleston dominating offensively and outshooting Wesleyan 34-12 despite standout defensive efforts from Francesca Sloan and Emma Adcock.

Lady Buc lacrosse team downs Morgantown, 9-5

The Buckhannon-Upshur Lady Buc lacrosse team snapped a two-game losing streak with a 9-5 win over Morgantown, led by Mallory Moss’s four goals and Kylie Hull’s 16 saves.

Lacrosse Bucs cruise past St. Albans for third straight win, 12-2

The Buckhannon-Upshur Buccaneers won their third consecutive lacrosse game, defeating St. Albans 12-2, led by three-goal performances from Braylon Oldaker, Forest Catlin, and Tobias Marple.

Leadership Upshur to host free Community Skills Share event at Parish House

Leadership Upshur and the Upshur Parish House are inviting residents of all ages to a free Community Skills Share event on May 7, featuring practical workshops, demonstrations and door prizes to foster learning and community connection.