Latest Updates

Carpenter Crunch Time Week 13: Playoff blowouts put WVSSAC’s postseason format back under fire

Four Class AAAA football blowouts reignited a familiar debate: Are too many teams making the playoffs? The WVSSAC will cut playoff berths from 16 to 12 in 2027, but that feels more like a bandage than a fix for competitive imbalance.

BUCKHANNON — The first round of the WVSSAC football playoffs is in the books, and in Class AAAA, the results were exactly what many expected.

If you missed it, the top four seeds rolled to victories by scores of 63-7, 63-0, 62-7 and 63-12.

Those lopsided outcomes reignited a debate that has lingered for years: Are too many teams qualifying for the postseason?

The WVSSAC has responded, at least partially. With reclassification looming, Class AAAA will consist of just 17 teams beginning in 2027. Allowing 16 of those 17 teams into the playoffs would have been difficult to justify, so the WVSSAC approved a reduction to 12 playoff berths.

While that is a step in the right direction, it feels more like a bandage than a true solution. Instead of addressing the larger issue of playoff expansion and competitive balance, the association essentially preserved the status quo. The numbers may change, but the underlying problem remains.

One social media argument did catch my attention, however.

Several people questioned why football’s playoff format receives so much criticism when every other high school sport allows all teams access to postseason play through regional tournaments.

It’s a fair point.

My response is that there is a significant difference between the two structures. In sports such as soccer, basketball and baseball, postseason brackets are largely organized geographically. Teams generally compete against nearby opponents, reducing travel and creating a more natural path toward state competition.

You don’t see a school like Parkersburg boarding a bus for a six-hour trip to Musselman only to face a heavily one-sided matchup. Yet that’s essentially what football’s playoff structure can create.

And, yes, before anyone points it out, Buckhannon-Upshur’s placement in the South Region remains its own separate discussion.

For another perspective on the WVSSAC playoff debate, check out Brian’s excellent column on the topic here.

Crunch Staff & Friends Leaderboard

NameOverallLast Week
Corrie62-223-4
Duane61-232-5
Bobbie60-241-6
Brian57-272-5
Katie46-383-4
Monica42-423-4

Last week was nothing short of disastrous for the staff.

I’ve been writing some version of this column for nearly 30 years, and I can’t remember a week when every member of the panel struggled this badly. Collectively, we posted a miserable 14-28 record, and not a single picker finished above .500.

The fallout shook up the standings.

Corrie now sits alone atop the leaderboard at 62-22, while I’m one game back at 61-23. Bobbie remains within striking distance at 60-24, followed by Brian (57-27), Katie (46-38) and Monica (42-42).

Fortunately, our readers performed much better.

In Week 12, Terri McCann was the lone participant to post a 6-1 record, eliminating the need for a tiebreaker. She earns this week’s $20 gift certificate to a local restaurant.

Todd Ware continues to lead the reader standings with 66 points, while William Parker owns the best overall record at 65-19.

As always, readers will select seven games each week, with Game 7 serving as the tiebreaker. Entries are due by 7 p.m. Friday before kickoff. Click here to make your picks for Week 13.

Now, let’s get to this week’s picks.

Week 13 Games

Winfield (9-2) at Elkins (10-1)

Elkins has enjoyed a dream season, but this feels like the spot where the run could end. That said, the Tigers possess one of the state’s most explosive offenses, and any team capable of scoring at that rate is dangerous. Don’t be surprised though, if Elkins finds a way to keep its remarkable season alive.

Duane: Winfield
Corrie: Elkins
Bobbie: Elkins
Brian: Elkins
Katie: Winfield

Monica: Pending

Morgantown (9-2) at Cabell Midland (10-1)

Morgantown’s only losses have come against Martinsburg and University, while Cabell Midland enters with a strong résumé of its own. Having watched the Knights against Buckhannon-Upshur, they’re clearly talented, but not unbeatable. The long trip south won’t be easy for the Mohigans, but I like Morgantown to leave Ona with a victory. Only Bobbie agrees with me.

Duane: Morgantown
Corrie: Cabell Midland
Bobbie: Morgantown
Brian: Cabell Midland
Katie: Cabell Midland

Monica: Pending

Houston (7-3) at West Virginia (5-5)

The less said about West Virginia’s season at this point, the better.

Last week’s loss to Kansas was a crushing setback and likely cost the Mountaineers their best opportunity to secure bowl eligibility. Until they prove otherwise, it’s difficult to trust them.

Duane: Houston
Corrie: Houston
Bobbie: Houston
Brian: Houston
Katie: West Virginia

Monica: Pending

The Final Four

Fairmont Senior (4-7) at Bridgeport (9-2)

Duane: Bridgeport
Corrie: Bridgeport
Bobbie: Bridgeport
Brian: Bridgeport
Katie: Bridgeport

Monica: Pending

Georgia State (5-5) at Marshall (5-5)

Duane: Marshall
Corrie: Georgia State
Bobbie: Marshall
Brian: Marshall
Katie: Georgia State

Monica: Pending

Pittsburgh (6-4) at Louisville (7-3)

Duane: Louisville
Corrie: Louisville
Bobbie: Louisville
Brian: Louisville
Katie: Pittsburgh

Monica: Pending

LSU (6-4) at Tennessee (8-2)

Duane: LSU
Corrie: Tennessee
Bobbie: LSU
Brian: Tennessee
Katie: Tennessee

Monica: Pending

*Monica did not submit her picks prior to deadline

Help Wanted

Central West Virginia Aging Services is hiring caregivers to serve elderly and disabled residents across the state. The nonprofit organization, which has been providing in-home services since 1974, has seven offices throughout West Virginia. Read more →

This story brought to you paywall-free, courtesy of the My Buckhannon team and our community partners

Around Town

  • Barnhart Insurance
  • In-⁠Home Services
  • St. Joseph's Hospital
  • Davis Health System
  • Twin Oaks Home Sales LLC
  • Davis Health System
  • Hank Ellis Insurance
  • WVU Medicine St. Joseph's Hospital
  • My Buckhannon

Advertise with us →

More Sports

Raising the Jolly Roger With… Alivia Cogar

Meet Alivia Cogar, a four-year varsity volleyball player who qualified for the state track meet in three events as a freshman. The Buckhannon-Upshur senior shares what she loves about Buccaneer grit and why it pays to “shake it out” after a mistake.

More sports →