On Friday, Cabell Midland beat Buckhannon-Upshur 63-12 in the first round of the Class AAAA football playoffs. It was the closest game involving any of the top four seeds in Quad A.
George Washington, Martinsburg, University and Cabell Midland all scored more than 60 points and won by at least 50.
Across West Virginia, 64 teams made the playoffs, 16 in each of four classes. The lower seed won only four of the 32 opening-round games; every higher seed advanced in Class AAAA. Upsets are supposed to be rare. Games decided by seven or eight touchdowns ought to be rare, too.
As My Buckhannon sports guru Duane Carpenter reported this week, the WVSSAC is cutting the Quad A playoff field from 16 teams to 12 in 2027. The class itself will shrink to 17 schools, and Buckhannon-Upshur will move down a division to Class AAA.
The 12-team AAAA bracket makes sense; imagine being the one school that didn’t make the playoffs under the old system. But why stop there?
Here’s an idea: ditch enrollment rules for AAAA and go with something entirely new. How about an eight-team playoff that takes the top teams at the end of the year, regardless of classification? Everyone else could still qualify for the playoffs in their regular class.
Call it the “Race for Eight” and picture how fun the regular season would be as teams jockey for those top spots.
Consider Bridgeport, which beat Chapmanville 56-7 in the Class AAA first round. Shouldn’t they get a chance to prove they’re the best of the best in the state? Not just the best of the second tier?
Maybe this idea didn’t make sense when kids grew up in a county and went to high school there all four years, back in the good ole days before mass consolidations and loose transfer rules.
But now? I’d rather see what a Race for Eight does for a Friday night in November than spend another four years guessing how competitive a team will be by counting the students in its hallways.
Fifty-point blowouts aren’t fun for anyone. West Virginia can do better.
Community Bulletin
Family medicine physician Andrew Colebank, DO, has joined WVU Medicine St. Joseph's Hospital at the Brushy Fork Rural Health Clinic in Buckhannon, where he is now scheduling patients of all ages for appointments beginning in October. Read more →
This story brought to you paywall-free, courtesy of the My Buckhannon team and our community partners
