Latest Updates

West Virginia State Auditor indicted on federal charges but can remain in office

Auditor Mark Hunt faces federal property theft and bank fraud charges but can remain in office. Removal would require a separate legal process or a felony conviction.

CHARLESTON — A federal grand jury has indicted West Virginia’s State Auditor on property theft and bank fraud charges, U.S. Attorney Moore Capito announced Monday.

Mark Hunt can remain in office while the criminal case proceeds. The indictment does not automatically remove him, though state law allows the governor or Legislature to pursue his removal before a criminal conviction.

Hunt, a Republican, won election on November 5, 2024, and took office in January 2025.

Four employees of the auditor’s office were also indicted. The charges involve tax-delinquent properties in Kanawha and Boone counties and government timecards prosecutors allege were falsified.

Hunt, 66, of Charleston, faces nine counts of theft of property. Three others face the same nine counts: Deputy Chief of Staff David Keith Cole, 57, who also manages Hunt’s private law office; General Counsel Frederic Scott Caudill, 59; and Special Counsel Robert Lisle Johns, 66. All three are from Charleston.

Cole and Caudill each face an additional count of making materially false statements to federal investigators. Separate bank fraud charges name Hunt, Cole and auditor’s office employee Marie Ann Hoffmann, 66, of Hurricane. Prosecutors allege Hoffmann carried out that scheme with Hunt’s and Cole’s assistance.

An indictment is an allegation. All five defendants are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt in court.

The property charges center on a business associated with Johns, whom prosecutors described as Hunt’s longtime friend and business associate. The business sought to purchase nine tax-delinquent properties through a process overseen by the auditor’s office.

Career employees in the office’s Land Division determined that none of the nine properties was legally eligible for deed issuance because the purchaser had missed required payments and paperwork deadlines, according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office.

Hunt signed and issued eight deeds March 28, 2025, and the ninth June 6, 2025, over those employees’ objections, the indictments allege. Johns was hired as the office’s full-time special counsel in June 2025.

Prosecutors allege Cole and Caudill helped create and issue the deeds, resulting in the theft of the properties from their lawful owners.

The bank fraud allegations cover a separate period, from about May 5, 2025, through at least about September 29, 2026. Prosecutors allege Hoffmann left her state duty station Friday afternoons to perform paralegal and administrative work at Mark A. Hunt & Associates while claiming those hours on government timecards.

Hunt knew Hoffmann was being paid state wages for that work, and Cole validated and approved the falsified timecards, the indictments allege. Hunt and Cole also frequently worked with her at the law firm during state business hours, prosecutors said.

The payments came from the West Virginia Treasury through the bank serving as the state’s primary designated depository, according to the announcement.

The false-statement charges concern FBI interviews with Cole on October 6 and Caudill on October 26. Prosecutors allege Cole made false statements about the deeds and approving Hoffmann’s timecards. Caudill allegedly made false statements about the deeds, including whether he asked staff “who will be the whistleblower” about their handling.

After Hunt acknowledged federal requests for records from his office, the disputed transfers drew legislative scrutiny before the indictments. In a November 10 letter, House and Senate Democrats asked House Speaker Roger Hanshaw and Senate President Randy E. Smith to seek a formal opinion from Attorney General JB McCuskey. They questioned Hunt’s authority to sign the deeds personally, whether deeds issued after statutory deadlines could be set aside and what remedies former owners might have.

Hunt had defended his actions in a November 9 MetroNews Talkline interview. He said he stepped in to sign deeds that had fallen behind and would have done so for anyone.

“I’m the boss; I’ll take the heat,” Hunt said in that interview.

The FBI and the West Virginia Commission on Special Investigations investigated the case. Assistant U.S. Attorneys Jonathan T. Storage and Joshua Hanks are prosecuting it.

“Public officials are entrusted to serve the people, not use their offices for personal benefit,” Capito said in the release. “When there is evidence that trust has been violated, our office will follow the facts and enforce the law, regardless of title or position.”

West Virginia Democratic Party Chair Mike Pushkin called for Hunt and the four indicted employees to resign immediately in a statement following the indictments.

“An indictment is not a conviction, and every defendant is entitled to due process,” Pushkin said. “But the people of West Virginia are also entitled to an Auditor’s Office whose leadership is above reproach.”

Under West Virginia’s removal law, Governor Patrick Morrisey can remove an elected state officer for official misconduct, malfeasance and other specified grounds. The required procedure includes written charges verified by affidavit, at least 20 days’ notice and a hearing. Removal requires satisfactory proof of the charges, and the officer can appeal to the state Supreme Court of Appeals.

The state Constitution also allows the House of Delegates to impeach a state officer for corruption, neglect of duty and other grounds. The Senate conducts the trial, and conviction requires two-thirds of all elected senators. That process is separate from a federal criminal prosecution.

A felony conviction would have a different consequence: state law says the office is vacated when its holder is convicted of a felony in any court, in or outside West Virginia.

If the auditor’s office becomes vacant, state law ordinarily requires Morrisey to appoint a successor from three qualified nominees submitted by the outgoing officeholder’s party executive committee. In Hunt’s case, that would be the Republican Party.

Help Wanted

Central West Virginia Aging Services is hiring caregivers to serve elderly and disabled residents across the state. The nonprofit organization, which has been providing in-home services since 1974, has seven offices throughout West Virginia. Read more →

This story brought to you paywall-free, courtesy of the My Buckhannon team and our community partners

Around Town

  • Twin Oaks Home Sales LLC
  • Barnhart Insurance
  • WVU Medicine St. Joseph's Hospital
  • My Buckhannon
  • Davis Health System
  • Jen Kesling
  • Kelley Tierney
  • WVU Medicine St. Joseph's Hospital
  • In-⁠Home Services
  • St. Joseph's Hospital

Advertise with us →

More Buckhannon News

More local news →