All schools in Upshur County will close at 1 p.m. today. All B-UHS sporting events today are canceled.

Upshur Sheriff: Escaped work crew prisoner sighted Tuesday is not believed to still be in the area, no history of violence

Denver F. Bennett

BUCKHANNON – The inmate who escaped custody while serving on a work crew in Elkins last week was seen off the Kesling Mill Road Tuesday, prompting another large-scale manhunt – this time in Upshur County – but to no avail.

According to a previous story, Denver F. Bennett, 30, of Valley Head, had been transported from the Pruntytown Correctional Center & Jail in Taylor County on Sept. 15 to Elkins as part of a work crew assisting the city with preparations for the Mountain State Forest Festival, which gets underway Sept. 30.

On Wednesday, Upshur County Sheriff Mike Coffman reassured residents that Bennett does not have a history of violence, and officers don’t believe he’s staying in the area.

Bennett initially eluded capture in Randolph County on Sept. 15, but Coffman confirmed Bennett had been spotted walking down a gravel road off Kesling Mill Road sometime Tuesday, Sept. 19.

“There was a 911 call, and the caller was sure that it was that individual because they had seen photos in the media,” the sheriff said. “We had units in the area at the time actually, so they were on scene within a matter of minutes and didn’t locate the subject. While we were out searching, I got flagged down by a guy who lives right there, and he said [Bennett] walked down this little gravel road right along the woods.”

Assisted by neighboring city and county units, West Virginia State Police, the U.S. Marshals Service and approximately 10 K-9 units, officers combed the area.

“We searched, and we didn’t find the individual, but we obtained camera footage from a nearby security camera, and it confirmed that the individual did indeed walk down that road, and we confirmed that he met the description of the escapee,” Coffman said.

According to video footage and sightings, Bennett has been seen on foot wearing khaki pants, white tennis shoes, a red flannel shirt and a ball cap, Coffman said.

Coffman urged residents to secure their homes and properties but said Bennett has no history of violence.

“They have assured us that he’s never been violent in the past,” Coffman said. “He’s stolen some items in the past, and he’s also fled from law enforcement officers numerous times in the past, but there’s no record of violence in his past.”

As previously reported, Bennett was convicted in Randolph County in 2018 for two counts of felony shoplifting and in Randolph County in 2022 for fleeing from an officer and fleeing from an officer in a vehicle, according to the West Virginia Division of Corrections and Rehabilitation Division’s website.

Coffman said deputies have been and continue to follow multiple leads.

“We’ve followed up on numerous leads that came into the 911 Center and that we received at the office all [Tuesday] night and all of today,” the sheriff said.

Coffman also said officers don’t believe Bennett is hiding in the area.

“After conferring with U.S. Marshals Service and other law enforcement officials, we don’t believe he’s holed up in the area or staying anywhere in the area here,” Coffman said. “I think it’s important for people to know that. We don’t feel that he’s remaining in the area where the Kesling Mill sighting was.”

Randolph County Sheriff Rob Elbon said his deputies assisted the Upshur County Sheriff’s Office in the search until about 11:30 p.m. Tuesday night.

“If we have a call, we’ll definitely be back out,” Elbon said Wednesday.

Share this story:

Local Businesses

RECENT Stories

LUCAS Truck

LUCAS to offer lung cancer screening in Rock Cave, Weston, and Buckhannon

LUCAS, WVU Medicine’s mobile lung cancer screening unit, will offer low-dose CT scans in Rock Cave, Weston, and Buckhannon in July for insured and eligible uninsured patients by appointment.

Man arrested for allegedly attempting to cash unauthorized check at BC Bank in Buckhannon

Christian Lyons, 47, of Ashford, was arrested on a felony charge after allegedly attempting to cash a check without authorization at a Buckhannon bank, with surveillance and account details helping police identify him.
Summer basketball

Summer Basketball League continues to grow under UCRC director Mitchell Shaw

The Upshur County Summer Basketball League, overseen by UCRC director Mitchell Shaw, is thriving and expanding with 18 teams and 183 players, offering organized, community-focused competition and new sponsorship-driven prizes in Buckhannon.

Buckhannon Banter: Get the local lowdown for June 11, 2025

Local highlights include a June 28 Glow Stick Party at James Curry Library, Upshur Schools’ virtual learning signups, BUHS rescheduled Alumni Soccer Game and a debut novel by Chantelle Kerr.

Upshur Update: Catch up on the latest local news in our June 11, 2025 podcast

The Upshur Update highlights the return of the Almost Heaven BBQ Bash, pool openings with new inclusive programs, community achievements in literacy and sports, student honors, local recognitions, and upcoming summer events in Buckhannon and Upshur County.

‘It’s the Small Things that Count’ – Lively pens book about daughter Megan

Alisa Mauk Lively has written “It’s the Small Things that Count,” a book celebrating the life and impact of her late daughter Megan, with proceeds benefiting Upshur County Special Olympics.

Buckhannon woman arrested for allegedly selling meth within 1,000 feet of local youth center

Tiffany Sparks, 43, was arrested after allegedly selling methamphetamine to a confidential informant within 1,000 feet of the Stockert Youth and Community Center in Buckhannon, according to police.

Read all about it: Rachel Strawder named new director of Literacy Volunteers of Upshur County

Rachel Strawder, a longtime member and former AmeriCorps VISTA, has been named the new director of Literacy Volunteers of Upshur County, succeeding Jennifer Higham and aiming to expand literacy outreach in the community.
asphalt pavement road paving work

City of Buckhannon to pave Randolph Street and other roads this week

The City of Buckhannon will begin paving southern Randolph Street on June 10, followed by Railroad Avenue, East Lincoln Street, and Maple Street, and asks residents to remove vehicles during the process.