Court hearing continued for man accused in fatal ‘shaken baby’ syndrome case

BUCKHANNON – An Upshur County magistrate granted a continuance in the preliminary hearing of a Buckhannon man who allegedly inflicted fatal traumatic brain injuries on his girlfriend’s two young children.

Thomas W. Cunningham, 27, is facing two counts of death of a child by parent, guardian or custodian by child abuse, a felony, after a two-year-boy and his one-year-old brother allegedly died from brain injuries suffered while in Cunningham’s care.

During a preliminary hearing in Upshur County Magistrate Court Monday, Cunningham’s state-appointed defense attorney, Jordan West, asked Magistrate Mark Davis to grant a motion for a continuance because his client “wanted to explore hiring a private defense attorney.”

Davis said that meant Cunningham would have to waive his right to a preliminary hearing within 10 days of his initial appearance, which was Dec. 9, 2022.

“That means you would be waiving the time period for your preliminary hearing — the waiver of your right to have it within 10 days of the initial appearance – do you understand that?” Davis asked Cunningham.

“Yes, sir,” Cunningham replied.

Upshur County Prosecuting Attorney Bryan Hinkle said he had no objection, and Davis granted the continuance. Cunningham is currently being held without bond in the Tygart Valley Regional Jail due to the nature of the offense, the penalty for which is 15 years to life in the state penitentiary.

According to the original story, Ciera N. Gillespie, 25, of Buckhannon — the mother of two-year-old Joseph Tyler Warner and one-year-old Hunter Haze Warner — allegedly left the two children and her six-year-old daughter in the care of Cunningham despite knowing he was under the influence of a controlled substance while she went to Walmart on the evening of Monday, Nov. 28, 2022.

The criminal complaint filed in the Upshur County Magistrate Clerk’s Office by Sgt. Rodney Rolenson with the Upshur County Sheriff’s Office says that when Gillespie returned home from Walmart Nov. 28, Cunningham reportedly came running out with the two-year-old, who had blood coming from his nose and mouth and was limp.

Upshur EMS was called to the scene, and both children were transported to J.W. Ruby Memorial Hospital in Morgantown, where the two-year-old, Joseph Tyler Warner, was pronounced dead Nov. 30 and the one-year-old, Hunter Haze Warner, died 10 days later on Dec. 10.

The children died from traumatic brain injuries consistent with ‘shaken baby syndrome,’ according to the file. During the course of his investigation, Rolenson interviewed WVU Medicine staff member Dr. Melvin Wright, who said the manner of death for the two-year-old was “traumatic injury consistent [with] ‘shaken baby’ [syndrome], and that the retinal injuries were the worse he had seen in 20 years,” the file states.

Wright stated that the injuries suffered by the one-year-old were also significant and resulted from shaken baby syndrome. Wright told police that “it would have to be violent trauma with immediate incapacitation.”

Gillespie, who is facing two counts of child neglect resulting in death, waived her preliminary hearing Dec. 15 in Upshur County Magistrate Court and remains incarcerated on a $200,000 cash-only bond after Magistrate Alan Suder denied a motion to modify it.



Consolidated board determines North Kanawha will remain a two-way street

BUCKHANNON – The Consolidated Public Works Board voted to keep North Kanawha Street a two-way street after previously considering making it a one-way road. The CPWB took up two previously discussed traffic items during their Jan. 26 meeting. The board […]

Become a premium member to unlock immediate access to this story — and thousands more. Free trial available! Signing up is easy — just tap the button below.

Barbour County man arrested for alleged sexual abuse of a juvenile in his care

BUCKHANNON — A Barbour County man who is listed on the West Virginia State Police’s Sex Offender Registry has been arrested for the alleged sexual abuse of a minor in his care. Kenneth D. Call, 52, of Belington, W.Va., was […]

Become a premium member to unlock immediate access to this story — and thousands more. Free trial available! Signing up is easy — just tap the button below.

Buckhannon: Then & Now – Big snow in Upshur County

Buckhannon: Then & Now. Join us in showcasing Upshur County throughout history and today. Much like today, Buckhannon has experienced major snow accumulations throughout history. Pictured here, Buckhannon received a record breaking accumulation of 40

County commission tasks new owner of Holly Apartments with cleaning up the site, will reevaluate in 90 days

BUCKHANNON – The Upshur County Commission has given the new owners of the Holly Apartments building in Adrian 90 days to clean up the property. The Holly Apartments were considered a total loss after a fire spread throughout the whole […]

Become a premium member to unlock immediate access to this story — and thousands more. Free trial available! Signing up is easy — just tap the button below.


Wesleyan lacrosse picked fifth in MEC preseason poll

BUCKHANNON, W.Va. – West Virginia Wesleyan women’s lacrosse has been selected to finish fifth in the Mountain East Conference, the league announced today. WVWC totaled nine points in the vote. Frostburg State and Notre Dame College tied

Swim Bucs head into Saturday’s conference championship meet coming off strong final performance at home

BUCKHANNON — The Buckhannon-Upshur High School boys and girls swim teams will head into the Big 10 Conference Championships on Saturday with the current at their backs after winning 10 events in their final home meet of the season. The […]

Become a premium member to unlock immediate access to this story — and thousands more. Free trial available! Signing up is easy — just tap the button below.

Owens steps down as head coach of Lady Bobcat soccer program

BUCKHANNON, W.Va. – Richard Owens has resigned as head coach of the West Virginia Wesleyan women’s soccer program, WVWC Athletic Department announced on Thursday. Owens spent five seasons as head coach of the Lady Bobcats,


Canaan Valley Resort to ski clinic for women Feb. 25-26

Davis, W.Va. (January 2023) – Offering more than seven hours of group and personalized ski instruction in a fun and supportive environment, Canaan Valley Resort will host a ski clinic for women by women February

Winter Blues Farmers Market returns Feb. 25

CHARLESTON, W.Va. — Winter Blues is back! The indoor farmers market makes its return on Saturday, February 25. More than 60 vendors from across West Virginia will be on hand to sell products grown and