All schools in Upshur County will close at 1 p.m. today. All B-UHS sporting events today are canceled.

Buckhannon woman charged with malicious wounding in kitchen knife incident

Benson

BUCKHANNON – A Buckhannon woman is facing two charges after West Virginia State Police were called to a domestic incident in which she allegedly cut the victim with a kitchen knife on Sunday.

Amanda Starr Benson, 38, has been charged with one felony count of malicious assault and one misdemeanor count of disorderly conduct after a verbal and physical argument occurred on St. Patrick’s Day, according to the criminal complaint in the Upshur County Magistrate Clerk’s Office.

The report, filed by investigating officer Trooper J.S. Tonkin with the Buckhannon detachment of the West Virginia State Police, says Benson and the victim advised the troopers that the two had been engaged in a verbal argument that turned physical inside their residence.

The victim stated that the argument was related to Benson leaving to see another man, and when she started to become agitated, she allegedly began to throw items throughout the home, the report says.

The victim further advised that when he attempted to retreat to the bedroom, Benson allegedly kicked in the door in an attempt to enter.

The report says the victim advised that he let Benson inside the room and then went into the bathroom in an attempt to get away from her. The victim also told police that Benson followed him to the bathroom and attempted to kick that door in as well, according to the complaint.

During the altercation, Benson allegedly picked up a black kitchen knife and began to “slash at and cut him with it,” the file says.

Officers observed four minor lacerations on the victim, one on his right bicep, one on his right lower abdomen, one on the left rib cage area and what appeared to be fingernail scratches on the right side of his neck, reports the criminal complaint.

However, the police report notes, “The victim displayed no marks consistent with physical abuse.”

After speaking with Benson, officers, including Tonkin, Senior Trooper P.J. Robinette and Cpl. B.K. Wright, were able to locate the knife partially hidden under a hand towel in the bathroom of the residence.

Once Benson was placed into custody outside of the residence, she began to yell and curse, states the complaint. Officers advised Benson to stop yelling and cursing several times; however, she continued to shout loud enough for neighbors to be disturbed.

Magistrate Mike Coffman set bail at $75,500.

If found guilty of the malicious assault charge, Benson could face not less than two nor more than ten years in a state correctional facility. If found guilty of the disorderly conduct charge, she may be confined in jail for 24 hours or fined not more than $100.

Share this story:

Local Businesses

RECENT Stories

Upshur County Commission partners with development authority, eyes $550k in grants for proposed rec hub

The Upshur County Commission partnered with the Development Authority and authorized applications for $550,000 in grants, as well as a joint property transfer, to support construction of the proposed John C. Allen Regional Hub recreation complex.

High Point Construction takes over lead in men’s golf league

High Point Construction took the top spot in the Buckhannon Country Club Bob Cupp Memorial Golf League after defeating Sam’s Pizza, while Highland Landscaping and Feola’s Flowers tied for second place.

Task force arrests three for selling Delta 8 to people under age 21, issues four additional warrants

After a year-long investigation, the Mountain Region Drug and Violent Crime Task Force arrested multiple individuals and issued warrants in Upshur County for allegedly selling Delta 8 THC products to individuals under 21.

ATV crash kills 65-year-old woman in Upshur County

Patricia L. Campbell, 65, of Ohio, died after being ejected from an ATV rollover crash in Upshur County on July 4; the investigation continues.

Willard Hampton Rice, Jr.

Willard Hampton Rice, Jr., 84, of Sandusky, a retired Ford Motor Company employee who enjoyed hunting and spending time with family, passed away July 3 and is survived by his wife, children, and grandchildren.

Buckhannon Banter: Get the local lowdown for July 2, 2025

This week in Buckhannon, local organizations plan events and clinics — including a big July 4th celebration — and several community initiatives aim to engage residents of all ages.

Emergency agencies stress need for coordinated incident plans during large events with road closures

Emergency officials emphasized the need for incident action plans and coordination with public safety agencies for large events that close major streets, citing upcoming car shows and other street-closure events to ensure fast, safe emergency responses.
BUHS Sports

B-U now in Class AAAA in all sports; moved to new South Region after WVSSAC restructuring

Buckhannon-Upshur High School will compete in Class AAAA — the highest division — for all sports and has been moved to the new South Region under a two-year realignment by the West Virginia Secondary School Activities Commission.

Stockert Youth and Community Center Board Meeting Agenda: July 3, 2025

The Stockert Youth and Community Center Board will meet July 3, 2025, with an agenda set to discuss organizational matters and upcoming events.