All schools in Upshur County will close at 1 p.m. today. All B-UHS sporting events today are canceled.

Buckhannon man arrested for allegedly stealing, selling valuable Gibson guitar

Hinkle

BUCKHANNON – An Upshur County man was arrested Saturday for allegedly stealing and selling a 1962 Gibson guitar.

Cody Hinkle, 28, of Buckhannon, was arrested for transferring and receiving stolen goods, a felony, in connection to an incident that allegedly occurred in November 2021.

According to the criminal complaint in the Upshur County Magistrate Clerk’s Office filed by investigating officer Trooper R.C. Watson with the Weston detachment of the West Virginia State Police, on Nov. 16, 2021, at 9:21 a.m., Watson received a call from WVSP Elkins Communication Center in reference to an alleged non-active breaking-and-entering on Harrison Avenue in Weston.

Watson responded and contacted the homeowner, who said his son previously lived in the residence, but it was currently unoccupied. The owner told police he had driven by the trailer on Monday and noticed the shed was open, which was abnormal since no one lived there, according to the file. The owner went to the trailer and noticed a window was broken, so he went inside and started looking around. At that point, he noticed his 1962 Gibson guitar was missing and it was a unique, expensive guitar, the police report says.

On the same day, Watson contacted local pawn shops to see if anyone pawned a similar guitar but did not find the guitar.

On Nov. 29, 2021, Watson, along with TFC. J.O. Hensley, contacted K&K Pawn Shop and inquired about the guitar. The employee at the pawnshop confirmed he had the guitar and set it aside, according to the report. The employee told police that a male named Cody Hinkle allegedly came into the store and sold the guitar for $50 on Nov. 15, 2021.

Watson subsequently contacted the homeowner, made him aware of the information and instructed him to go to the pawnshop and identify the guitar and confirm it was his.

At about 11:30 that day, the homeowner arrived at the WVSP Weston detachment and confirmed the guitar was his. He provided Watson with the buyers’/sellers’ report, given to him by the pawnshop.

The value of the guitar was estimated at $2,500, the file states.

Upshur County Magistrate Alan Suder set bail at $10,000 cash or surety, and as of Wednesday evening, Hinkle remained incarcerated in the Central Regional Jail, according to the West Virginia Jail & Correctional Facility Authority website.

The penalty for a conviction of transferring and receiving stolen goods is confinement in the state penitentiary for not less than one year nor more than 10 years, or in the discretion of the court, confinement in jail for not more than one year and a fine of not more than $2,500.

Share this story:

RECENT Stories

Mother arrested for child neglect after police find wanted man, drugs in home

Latachia A. Weese, 30, was arrested and charged with felony child neglect after allegedly admitting to being high while caring for her two young children in a residence containing drugs and firearms.

Buckhannon man arrested for allegedly choking his mother

Timothy A. Tenney, 37, of Buckhannon, was arrested and charged with felony strangulation and misdemeanor domestic battery after allegedly attacking and choking his mother.

Edna Karickhoff

Edna Karickhoff, 91, a homemaker and member of Pleasant Valley United Methodist Church, died May 19, 2025, and is survived by her children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren; funeral services are Thursday.

Strawberry Festival parade showcases power of music to connect communities — and cultures

A musical exchange between Bridgeport High School and Carmen Southeast High brought Appalachian and Latin rhythms — and award-winning performances — to the West Virginia Strawberry Festival, fostering cross-cultural friendships and greater musical understanding among students.

Buckhannon-Upshur’s mountain bike trails see major growth thanks to dedicated volunteers

Thanks to the volunteer-driven Upshur County Trails group, Buckhannon-Upshur’s mountain bike trail system has expanded to about 10 miles, supporting biking, hiking, and community events while fostering local partnerships and youth engagement.

WVWC Student Senate names faculty, staff members of the year

The West Virginia Wesleyan College Student Senate honored Dr. Alexis de Coning and Amy Rogosky as Faculty and Staff Members of the Year for their exceptional dedication to students and the campus community.

Appalachian Fly Fishing Festival returns to Thomas from May 30 – June 1

The Appalachian Fly Fishing Festival returns to Thomas, WV, May 30–June 1, offering expanded clinics, vendors, competitions, family activities, and community gatherings for anglers of all ages and skill levels.

This week’s Hank Ellis All-Stars: Jaxon Spratt and Rylen Carlyle

Jaxon Spratt, a standout baseball catcher, and Rylen Carlyle, a talented track athlete, were named this week’s Hank Ellis All-Stars for their performances in regional competition for Buckhannon-Upshur.
BUHS Golf Feature Image

Parker and Westfall to represent B-U in North-South All-Star Golf Tournament

Buckhannon-Upshur seniors Parker Lockwood and Jevon Westfall will represent the North Bears in the second annual North-South All-Star Golf Tournament at Little Creek Golf Course, joining seven other top high school golfers.

Buckhannon Banter: Get the local lowdown for May 20, 2025

Buckhannon residents can look forward to the Jack Barker Memorial Race & Fun Paddle, school art show reception, FFA greenhouse sale, and a community book swap event at The Yellow Door.

Allyson Peters Lewis honored with prestigious honorary American FFA degree at National FFA Convention & Expo

Allyson Peters Lewis, a dedicated agricultural educator, has been awarded the prestigious Honorary American FFA Degree for her long-standing commitment to advancing agricultural education and inspiring student success nationwide.

Retired firefighters Jim Gregory and Brian Hollen recognized for service and sacrifice

Retired Buckhannon Volunteer Firefighters Jim Gregory and Brian Hollen were honored by the Buckhannon Fire Department for their years of service and sacrifice during the annual Friendly Way Day celebration.