All schools in Upshur County will close at 1 p.m. today. All B-UHS sporting events today are canceled.

Buckhannon man arrested for allegedly stealing, selling valuable Gibson guitar

Hinkle

BUCKHANNON – An Upshur County man was arrested Saturday for allegedly stealing and selling a 1962 Gibson guitar.

Cody Hinkle, 28, of Buckhannon, was arrested for transferring and receiving stolen goods, a felony, in connection to an incident that allegedly occurred in November 2021.

According to the criminal complaint in the Upshur County Magistrate Clerk’s Office filed by investigating officer Trooper R.C. Watson with the Weston detachment of the West Virginia State Police, on Nov. 16, 2021, at 9:21 a.m., Watson received a call from WVSP Elkins Communication Center in reference to an alleged non-active breaking-and-entering on Harrison Avenue in Weston.

Watson responded and contacted the homeowner, who said his son previously lived in the residence, but it was currently unoccupied. The owner told police he had driven by the trailer on Monday and noticed the shed was open, which was abnormal since no one lived there, according to the file. The owner went to the trailer and noticed a window was broken, so he went inside and started looking around. At that point, he noticed his 1962 Gibson guitar was missing and it was a unique, expensive guitar, the police report says.

On the same day, Watson contacted local pawn shops to see if anyone pawned a similar guitar but did not find the guitar.

On Nov. 29, 2021, Watson, along with TFC. J.O. Hensley, contacted K&K Pawn Shop and inquired about the guitar. The employee at the pawnshop confirmed he had the guitar and set it aside, according to the report. The employee told police that a male named Cody Hinkle allegedly came into the store and sold the guitar for $50 on Nov. 15, 2021.

Watson subsequently contacted the homeowner, made him aware of the information and instructed him to go to the pawnshop and identify the guitar and confirm it was his.

At about 11:30 that day, the homeowner arrived at the WVSP Weston detachment and confirmed the guitar was his. He provided Watson with the buyers’/sellers’ report, given to him by the pawnshop.

The value of the guitar was estimated at $2,500, the file states.

Upshur County Magistrate Alan Suder set bail at $10,000 cash or surety, and as of Wednesday evening, Hinkle remained incarcerated in the Central Regional Jail, according to the West Virginia Jail & Correctional Facility Authority website.

The penalty for a conviction of transferring and receiving stolen goods is confinement in the state penitentiary for not less than one year nor more than 10 years, or in the discretion of the court, confinement in jail for not more than one year and a fine of not more than $2,500.

Share this story:

RECENT Stories

Literacy Volunteers of Upshur County celebrates community support and grant impact

Literacy Volunteers of Upshur County thanked community members and grantors for crucial support that enabled the nonprofit to provide free, life-changing tutoring services for adult learners, emphasizing the broad impact of improved literacy.

Strawberry Festival Quilt Show Winners Announced

Susanne Thompson’s Longwood Gardens quilt swept both Best in Show and People’s Choice at the Strawberry Festival Quilt Show, with major honors also awarded to Mary Ellen Lemons, Sarah Sanders, Diana Kerr and others.

Loren Matthew Wimer

Loren Matthew Wimer, 58, of Ireland, a devoted family man, outdoors enthusiast, and logger, passed away on May 27, 2025, leaving behind loving relatives and friends who will honor his memory at services on June 1.

Lillian Carol Gibson

Lillian Carol “Peach” Gibson, a Buckhannon native and longtime Pittsburgh resident known for her career at U.S. Steel, artistic achievements, and support of local history, has died at Vincentian Schenley Gardens.

Buckhannon Colonial Arts Center Board Agenda: June 3, 2025

The City of Buckhannon Colonial Arts Center Board has released the agenda for its upcoming June 3, 2025 meeting.

Marion Street neighbors push for reduced speed limit and improved stop signs

The Buckhannon Consolidated Public Works Board will ask the state to lower Marion Street’s speed limit to 25 mph and consider a flashing stop sign at Camden Avenue, but declined requests for speed bumps on Pocahontas Street.

Buckhannon man arrested on 49 counts of fraudulent use of access device

A Buckhannon man faces 49 charges after allegedly making dozens of unauthorized purchases using someone else’s account, totaling over $6,000.

Sylvia Ann Wolford

Sylvia Ann Wolford, 59, of Buckhannon, WV, passed away at her home on May 26, 2025, leaving behind six children, extended family, and her companion, with funeral services scheduled for June 2.

Local Music Night concert series extended through summer with new sponsors Klie Law Offices and Strategy IT

Local Music Night at Colonial Arts Center will extend its free, all-ages concert series through August, offering local musicians a platform to perform thanks to new sponsorship from Klie Law Offices and Strategy IT.

Buckhannon City Council to consider imposing new fee to fund street and park projects

The Buckhannon City Council is set to vote on authorizing the drafting of a new municipal fee aimed at raising $200,000 annually to fund street, sidewalk and park maintenance.

Color our world: Upshur County Public Library announces summer reading program

The Upshur County Public Library invites all ages to join its June summer reading program, “Color Our World,” featuring art-themed activities, prizes, a community art show, and registration now open online and at the library.

On the City of Buckhannon calendar: Week of May 26, 2025

The City of Buckhannon has announced a May 28 public zoning hearing, a May 31 wrestling event, upcoming bid opportunities for city services, and reminders for utility payments and repair reporting.