All schools in Upshur County will close at 1 p.m. today. All B-UHS sporting events today are canceled.

WVU College of Law clinic case is headed to the U.S. Supreme Court

A case being handled by a clinic at the West Virginia University College of Law will be argued in the United States Supreme Court on Dec. 3.

WVU Law students in the U.S. Supreme Court Clinic have been preparing for Dawson v. Steager, a tax discrimination case, for 18 months. They conducted much of the required research, analysis and writing for the case under the leadership of Lawrence Rosenberg, a partner with Jones Day in Washington, DC, and Anne Marie Lofaso, professor of law.

Rosenberg will argue the case before the Supreme Court. He and Lofaso founded the U.S. Supreme Court Clinic at WVU in 2011.

“This is a truly transformative experience for the WVU law students who have worked on this case,” said Gregory Bowman, dean of the College of Law. “Their work is critically important to a case that is going to be ruled on by the highest court in the land and will establish meaningful precedent. Only a handful of law schools in the country can provide this opportunity to their students.”

At issue in Dawson v. Steager is whether the State of West Virginia can impose a heavier tax burden on federal retirees than it imposes on state retirees who performed the same job duties.

It is the position of James and Elaine Dawson, clients of the WVU U.S. Supreme Court Clinic, that the state must extend favorable tax treatment of state employees to similarly situated federal employees.

West Virginia, on the other hand, argues that it can tax the benefits of federal and state retirees differently as long as it only favors a specific and small group of retirees.

At the heart of the case is James Dawson. A retired presidentially appointed U.S. Marshal for the Southern District of West Virginia, Dawson was enrolled exclusively in the Federal Employee Retirement System (FERS). He sought a state tax exemption for all of his retirement income, but was denied by the West Virginia Supreme Court.

Under West Virginia law, Dawson is entitled to exempt only a small portion of his FERS income from state tax. However, West Virginia allows most state law enforcement retirees to exempt all of their state benefits from state tax.

According to the law clinic’s argument, several U.S. Supreme Court decisions support Dawson including Davis v. Michigan Department of Treasury (1989) and Jefferson County, Alabama v. Acker (1999).

The WVU Law students found that three state appeals courts have struck down tax laws that discriminate against federal employees, but three state appeals courts have also upheld such laws. Other state courts of last resort have ruled inconsistently on related laws.

The Supreme Court’s ruling on Dawson v. Steager is expected by the end of June 2019.

Share this story:

Local Businesses

RECENT Stories

Buckhannon Banter: Get the local lowdown for July 2, 2025

This week in Buckhannon, local organizations plan events and clinics — including a big July 4th celebration — and several community initiatives aim to engage residents of all ages.

Emergency agencies stress need for coordinated incident plans during large events with road closures

Emergency officials emphasized the need for incident action plans and coordination with public safety agencies for large events that close major streets, citing upcoming car shows and other street-closure events to ensure fast, safe emergency responses.
BUHS Sports

B-U now in Class AAAA in all sports; moved to new South Region after WVSSAC restructuring

Buckhannon-Upshur High School will compete in Class AAAA — the highest division — for all sports and has been moved to the new South Region under a two-year realignment by the West Virginia Secondary School Activities Commission.

Stockert Youth and Community Center Board Meeting Agenda: July 3, 2025

The Stockert Youth and Community Center Board will meet July 3, 2025, with an agenda set to discuss organizational matters and upcoming events.

Buckhannon Waste Board Agenda: July 3, 2025

The City of Buckhannon Waste Collection Board has released the agenda for its upcoming meeting on July 3, 2025.

Woman arrested on six felony charges after allegedly shooting at a man in Upshur County

Jocelyn M. Krum, 28, of Charleston, was arrested on six felony charges after allegedly entering a Mt. Lebanon Road residence in Upshur County with a rifle and shooting at a man before fleeing the scene.

Buckhannon man sentenced to 11 to 21 years for Bailey Ridge Road shootout

Austin W. Arbogast, 26, was sentenced to 11 to 21 years in prison after pleading guilty to four felony charges stemming from a March 2024 shootout on Bailey Ridge Road while attempting to retrieve his child.

Mountain East Conference extends invitation to Shawnee State University

The Mountain East Conference has approved Shawnee State University as its 12th full-time member, with the school set to join in 2026 pending NCAA Division II acceptance and expanding league competition in 19 sports.
Davis and Elkins College

Davis & Elkins College students recognized for high academic honors for Spring 2025 semester

Davis & Elkins College has announced the Spring 2025 president’s list, for students earning 4.0 GPAs, and dean’s list, for those earning 3.6 to 3.99, honoring academic excellence campus-wide.