All schools in Upshur County will close at 1 p.m. today. All B-UHS sporting events today are canceled.

Upshur residents arrested for child neglect after alleged intoxication, failing to care for their toddler

BUCKHANNON – The parents of a three-year-old toddler were arrested Saturday for child neglect after several 911 calls were placed in one day regarding their behavior.  

Bobbie R. Nixon, 30, and Allen J. Nuttle, 45, both of Buckhannon, were each arrested on one count of child neglect creating a risk of serious injury, a felony.

According to the criminal complaint in the Upshur County Magistrate Clerk’s Office filed by Sgt. Marshall O’Connor with the Buckhannon Police Department, on Saturday, Sept. 24, 2022, officers with the Buckhannon Police Department responded to a Cleveland Avenue residence for a removal of an unwanted person.

The file says that when police arrived on scene, officers spoke with Bobbie Nixon, the child’s mother, who advised that her boyfriend, Allen Nuttle, the child’s father, had reportedly kept her up all night and due to that, the two began arguing.

While officers were on scene, Nuttle contacted Nixon and stated that would like to speak with law enforcement officers to give his side of the story. O’Connor went to speak with Nuttle, who reportedly told police Nixon kept him up all night and that “when she is off her [psychiatric] medicine, she begins to behave in the manner police officers witnessed,” O’Connor wrote in the report.

Law enforcement officers subsequently provided Nuttle with a phone number he could use to secure help for Nixon.

Then, approximately three hours and 15 minutes later, officers received a second 911 call related to this incident. This 911 call came from a witness who advised that Nixon had taken her and Nuttle’s three-year-old child to another residence on Cleveland Avenue, the police report says.

The 911 caller also said that Nixon had allegedly informed her and her son that the three-year-old was “up for adoption” and proceeded to ask the caller’s son to adopt the child, according to the complaint. According to the report, the caller’s son said no, and Nixon then “said goodbye and left.” At this point, the caller dialed 911 and contacted Child Protective Services.

Then, about 52 minutes after the second 911 call, a third 911 call was placed. This call was to inform police and first responders that Nuttle, the child’s father, was allegedly found in his residence “slumped over, in a chair and unable to wake,” the police report says. Upshur County EMS and the Buckhannon Fire Department responded to provide aid to Nuttle, and after Nuttle was woken up, EMS checked his vital signs and asked him to go to the hospital.

However, Nuttle refused.

During this incident, O’Connor spoke with Nuttle, who allegedly appeared to be intoxicated and was unable to comprehend what O’Connor was attempting to explain to him. O’Connor then left the residence to assist BPD officer Patrolman First Class Angel McCauley with the child. A witness had advised police that Nuttle allegedly “slapped Nixon in the face with a diaper that was filled with feces,” the criminal complaint states.

Moreover, officers saw photographs that showed Nixon with “a brown substance smeared across the right side of her face and in her hair,” according to the file.

Approximately 25 minutes later, O’Connor returned to arrest Nuttle who was unable to tell law enforcement where his child was and still couldn’t understand what police were trying to explain to him. Shortly after, Nixon was found sitting on the side of Reynolds Lane, allegedly wearing only a T-shirt and holding a book. Nixon was also taken into custody.

Officers obtained search warrants to determine the level of controlled substances and/or alcohol in both parents’ systems because Nixon and Nuttle seemed to be incapable of caring for their toddler.

Upshur County Magistrate Mark Davis set bail at $25,000 cash or surety for both Nixon and Nuttle.

The potential penalty for a conviction of child neglect creating risk of serious injury is confinement in a state penitentiary for not less than one nor more than five years, a fine of not less than $1,000 nor more than $3,000, or both.

Share this story:

RECENT Stories

Festival Fridays

Swing into Summer: Festival Fridays returns with Rockin’ Red Sky Down and new Jawbone Park swings

Festival Fridays returns this summer with Red Sky Down headlining the opening event, a new city-built stage, over 25 vendors, diverse musical acts each week, and community activities organized by Create Buckhannon at Jawbone Park.

Tallmansville man arrested for allegedly selling meth to a confidential informant last fall

Christopher R. Taylor, also known as Chris Linger, was arrested for allegedly selling methamphetamine within 1,000 feet of a school.

Local percussionist Lila Wright to attend world-renowned Interlochen Arts Camp

Lila June Wright, a rising senior and percussionist from Buckhannon-Upshur High School, has been selected to attend the prestigious Interlochen Arts Camp this summer, studying alongside young artists from around the world.

‘One day at a time,’ Katie Morgan overcomes challenges to become outstanding senior at Wesleyan

Despite being totally blind and a first-generation college student, West Virginia Wesleyan College graduate Katie Morgan ’25 excelled academically and in campus service, earning multiple prestigious awards and graduating summa cum laude in psychology.

ART26201 to host 10th Annual Young Filmmakers Camp in August

ART26201, in collaboration with West Virginia Wesleyan College, will hold its 10th annual Young Filmmakers Camp August 4-8, 2025, offering students ages 12 and up hands-on instruction in filmmaking at LASCAUX Micro-Theater.

Buckhannon Banter: Get the local lowdown for June 2, 2025

Buckhannon’s latest updates include free pool admission for school staff, online ‘Mamma Mia!’ ticket sales, a historic restaurant grant campaign, a student scholarship finalist, a new care facility opening, a charity golf scramble, and a community art show.

Buckhannon man faces five charges after allegedly fleeing from crash while drunk

Kenneth Ray Johnson of Buckhannon was arrested after allegedly fleeing a crash and now faces five charges, including DUI, possession of marijuana, and driving while revoked following prior DUI convictions.

City of Buckhannon calendar for the week of June 2, 2025

Buckhannon city officials have announced this week’s schedule of public meetings, recycling pickups, summer events such as Festival Fridays, upcoming bid opportunities, utility bill information, and a proposed zoning amendment for resident consideration.

Mary Ellen Corder

Mary Ellen Corder, 92, a longtime Buckhannon resident, homemaker, and member of Reger Chapel United Methodist Church, passed away at her home May 28 with funeral services scheduled for June 5.

Buckhannon City Council Agenda: June 5, 2025

The Buckhannon City Council has released the agenda for its upcoming meeting on June 5, 2025.

Community Corrections Board hiring part-time case aide in Upshur and Lewis counties

The Community Corrections Board is hiring a part-time Case Aide in Upshur or Lewis counties to assist with client supervision and office duties, with applications due by June 13, 2025.

Schedule set for WVSSAC state baseball tournament

Sixteen high school teams will compete in the inaugural four-class WVSSAC state baseball tournament at GoMart Ballpark in Charleston June 5-7, with semifinals on Thursday and Friday and championships on Saturday.