All schools in Upshur County will close at 1 p.m. today. All B-UHS sporting events today are canceled.

Trial of man accused in fatal ‘shaken baby’ syndrome case delayed due to incomplete death investigation reports

BUCKHANNON – The case of an Upshur County man accused of inflicting fatal traumatic brain injuries on his girlfriend’s two young children has been delayed due to incomplete death investigation reports.

In Upshur County Circuit Court Thursday, 26th Judicial Circuit Court Judge Jacob Reger granted a motion filed by Upshur County Prosecuting Attorney Bryan Hinkle on behalf of the state asking to continue the pretrial hearing of Thomas W. Cunningham, 28, of Buckhannon, until the next regular term of Upshur County Circuit Court.

Cunningham was indicted on two felony counts of death of a child by a guardian or custodian or other person by child abuse during the May 2023 term of Circuit Court. The charges came after a two-year-boy and his one-year-old brother allegedly died from brain injuries suffered while in Cunningham’s care in November 2022.

The children’s mother, Ciera Nicole Gillespie, 26, of Buckhannon, was also indicted for two felony counts of child neglect resulting in death in May 2023.

Hinkle told the court he had filed the motion for continuance because the West Virginia Office of the Chief Medical Examiner had not yet issued death investigation reports and post-mortem findings after conducting the autopsies.

Hinkle said he had made multiple attempts to secure those reports, even issuing a subpoena to the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner April 19, 2023.

The office then contacted the prosecuting attorney’s office to inform them that the death investigation reports and post-mortem findings were not yet available because samples were submitted to a special laboratory outside the state of West Virginia that could analyze the tissue.

Hinkle noted that there’s nowhere in West Virginia capable of performing that type of analysis.

Cunningham’s attorney, Zachary Dyer, said he had no objection to continuing the case until the next term of court, which begins in September 2023.

Reger acknowledged the serious nature of the case and granted the motion for continuance. Cunningham’s pretrial is now set for 10:45 a.m. Oct. 30, 2023, and jury selection will be Nov. 13, 2023 with the trial set to follow on Nov. 14.

According to the original complaint, on Nov. 28, 2022, when Gillespie, the children’s mother, returned home from Walmart, Cunningham reportedly came running out with the two-year-old, who had blood coming from his nose and mouth and was limp. Upshur EMS was called to the scene and transported both infants to St. Joseph’s Hospital and then Ruby Memorial Hospital.

Upshur County Sheriff’s Deputy Sgt. Rodney Rolenson, the investigating officer, interviewed WVU Medicine staff member Dr. Melvin Wright, who said the manner of death for the two-year-old was “traumatic injury consistent [with] ‘shaken baby’ [syndrome], and that the retinal injuries were the worse he had seen in 10 years,” the file states.

Wright also stated that the injuries suffered by the one-year-old were also significant and also resulted from shaken baby syndrome. Wright told police that “it would have to be violent trauma with immediate incapacitation.

Share this story:

Local Businesses

RECENT Stories

Really Really Free Market and Community Potluck scheduled for Sunday, July 13

A community Really Really Free Market and potluck will be held Sunday, July 13, from 1–3 pm at Walnut and Chestnut streets, featuring free goods, services, food and opportunities to connect and volunteer.

Man arrested for attempted murder after allegedly attempting to run someone over in Walmart parking lot

Rayne Prince Marion Chuma was arrested and charged with attempted murder after allegedly trying to hit a man with his vehicle in the Buckhannon Walmart parking lot before leaving the scene.

Suspect held without bail in Brushy Fork Road robbery case

Bruno Martins Ferreira has been arrested and is being held without bail on felony robbery and conspiracy charges after allegedly participating in an armed robbery at a Brushy Fork Road residence, during which $12,000 was transferred from the victim’s bank account.

Upshur County Board of Education Agenda: July 8, 2025

The Upshur County Board of Education has released the agenda for its upcoming meeting scheduled for July 8, 2025.

City of Buckhannon calendar: July 7-11, 2025

Buckhannon has announced a series of July public meetings, bulky item and yard waste collections, family-friendly events such as Festival Fridays, deadline reminders for firefighter applications, and performances of “Mamma Mia!” at the Colonial Arts Center.

Sherry Esenwein

Sherry Esenwein, a devoted educator, animal lover, and Buckhannon native, passed away peacefully at 71 in Annapolis, remembered for her adventurous spirit, cherished family, and lifelong dedication to teaching and her beloved dogs.

Summer Basketball League kicks off

The Upshur County Summer Basketball League began its season last week, featuring multiple games with standout performances from players such as Josh Trent, Andrew Holcomb, and Sterlin Thropp, while several matches ended in forfeits.

Post 7 falls in twin bill to Charleston

Buckhannon Post 7 suffered two losses to Charleston Post 56 on Sunday, dropping the first game 14-0 by mercy rule and falling 5-2 in the second despite a late rally.

Upshur County Commission partners with development authority, eyes $550k in grants for proposed rec hub

The Upshur County Commission partnered with the Development Authority and authorized applications for $550,000 in grants, as well as a joint property transfer, to support construction of the proposed John C. Allen Regional Hub recreation complex.