All schools in Upshur County will close at 1 p.m. today. All B-UHS sporting events today are canceled.

Man arrested for child neglect in Main Street fire case

Tyler

BUCKHANNON – A Buckhannon man who allegedly left a needle within reach of his three young children and was not home when a fire broke out at the family’s Main Street apartment was arrested for child neglect Wednesday.

The Buckhannon Police Department had been searching for Melvin A. Tyler Jr., 29, since the day the apartment he lived in with his three children – a five-year-old, six-year-old and seven-year-old – caught on fire.

According to a previous story, the fire occurred at about 1 p.m. on Saturday, June 20, and was contained to one room in an apartment above Merle Norman and the Pink Hydrangea at 11 1/2 E. Main St.

The criminal complaint, filed by Patrolman Angel McCauley, charges Tyler with child neglect creating risk of serious injury, a felony.

According to the file, when McCauley responded to the Main Street to assist the Buckhannon Fire Department with a structure fire, she found the three children and their grandfather behind the building. The grandfather reportedly told police that one of the children had started the fire.

Law enforcement tried unsuccessfully to find Tyler, their father; however, he later showed up at the scene.

The fire department requested McCauley perform a ‘walk-through’ of the apartment because of “questionable items,” and when she did, McCauley allegedly found a plastic container holding several razor blades and an “uncapped loaded needle … within reach of the children.”

McCauley noted the grandfather suffered from psychological conditions that made him incapable of supervising the children, and that their father, Tyler, was aware of the conditions. When police talked with the grandfather after the fire was put out, he told them that he had been taking a nap on the couch in the Main Street apartment, and when he woke up, he discovered that Tyler had left the residence. The grandfather said he felt obligated to stay with the children so they wouldn’t be alone.

“He also stated they were getting ready to ride hover boards when [one of the children] came into the room and told him there was a fire,” McCauley wrote in the report. “After attempting to put it out, [the grandfather] made sure the kids got out of the building safely. “

“Several family members stated that Melvin (Tyler) has a history of disappearing for hours and the kids are often left with whoever will watch them with no regards to the children’s personal safety,” the report says.

The complaint also notes that the owners of a Main Street business had filed complaints about the children being left unsupervised for multiple-hour periods. While on patrol, officers with the city police department have often seen the children unsupervised, the file says.

Tyler was also charged with being a person prohibited from possessing a firearm, a misdemeanor, related to a May 5, 2020, incident, according to a second criminal complaint filed by Sgt. William Courtney with the BPD.

Bail was set at $35,000 cash or surety, and Tyler remained incarcerated as of Thursday evening.

Share this story:

Local Businesses

RECENT Stories

Summer basketball

Summer league basketball wraps up week two

Week two of the Upshur County Summer Basketball League concluded with standout scoring performances and multiple games, including two forfeits by Country Roads Physical Therapy.

City council to review water board’s recommendation for new water treatment plant

The Buckhannon Water Board has recommended moving forward with a new water treatment plant and related infrastructure upgrades, sending a proposal to the city council for approval.

Gail Lovel Zickefoose

Gail L. Zickefoose, a dedicated educator, community leader, and beloved family man, passed away peacefully at age 83 after a long illness, leaving a legacy of service, kindness, and devotion to others.

Buckhannon City Council Agenda: July 15, 2025

The Buckhannon City Council released the agenda for its upcoming July 15, 2025, meeting.

Upshur County Relay for Life aims to raise $35,000 for cancer research on July 19

The Upshur County Relay for Life will host its annual event July 19 at Jawbone Park, aiming to raise $35,000 for cancer research while celebrating survivors and bringing the community together through activities and remembrance ceremonies.

WVU Medicine St. Joseph’s Hospital team members engage in statewide healthcare leadership program

Two WVU Medicine St. Joseph’s Hospital employees were honored by the West Virginia Hospital Association Leadership Academy, with Paula Cutright graduating and Matthew Scott selected for future participation in the statewide healthcare leadership program.

Post 7 drops outings to Doddridge and Morgantown

Buckhannon Post 7 suffered consecutive road defeats, falling 10-2 to Doddridge County and 11-0 to Morgantown Post 2, dropping their season record to 2-15.

Summer basketball league begins week two

The Upshur County Summer Basketball League entered its second week with standout performances from top scorers including Cory Harper, Dalton Hamrick, Cordell Nicola, and Vinny Snuffer leading their teams across multiple games.

Buckhannon City Council Special Meeting Agenda: July 15, 2025

The Buckhannon City Council has released the agenda for its special meeting scheduled for July 15, 2025.